Can I modify a vintage full-frame 50mm lens into a 35mm lens for APS-C and keep infinity focus?
Asked 1/12/2022
6 views
2 answers
0
I have a cheap vintage 50mm f/2.8 full-frame lens and want a wider field of view on an APS-C camera, closer to 35mm equivalent. If I place the lens closer to the sensor, the angle of view changes somewhat, but it no longer focuses properly. The lens has 4 elements, with the rear two apparently cemented together. Can changing the spacing between elements restore focus, or is there a better way to do this? I'm looking for a plain-language explanation.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
4y ago
2 Answers
5
This is exactly what a telecompressor/focal reducer/"speed booster" is for. It can be bought as a ready made unit with a choice of mirrorless camera mounts on one side and a choice of SLR/DSLR mounts on the other. Since these devices are more expensive than normal adapters, it can be worth buying strategically in case you have multiple legacy mounts in use (eg buy a telecompressor that accepts Canon EF mount lenses, since simple and inexpensive adapters for a lot of other camera mounts exist for EF mount).
Originally by user58185. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user58185
4y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
In practice, no—you generally can’t turn a 50mm lens into a 35mm lens just by changing element spacing and still expect it to focus well. Vintage lenses were carefully optimized, and even small internal spacing changes usually hurt sharpness and introduce aberrations. On many simple 4-element designs, focusing is done by moving the whole optical unit together, not by changing internal element spacing.
Moving the lens closer to the sensor changes where it focuses, but it does not correctly redesign the lens into a shorter focal length. That’s why focus breaks, especially at infinity.
The proper tool for this is a focal reducer (also called a telecompressor or speed booster). It adds optics between the lens and camera to reduce the effective focal length and give a wider angle of view on APS-C, while preserving normal focusing behavior far better than modifying the lens itself.
Some lens-specific hacks exist, but they are exceptions and usually reduce image quality. So the practical answer is: don’t alter the internal lens spacing unless you’re experimenting and accept worse results; use a focal reducer or buy a wider lens instead.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI4y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Does a 35mm lens on APS-C cause the same portrait distortion as 35mm on full frame?
Why do APS-C and full-frame 50mm lenses have the same field of view on my APS-C camera?
How do I calculate a lens’s field of view on APS-C from its full-frame angle of view?
Why can a 50mm f/2 lens have the same aperture on APS-C and full frame, yet a different field of view?
Which lens gives a 50mm full-frame field of view on a Nikon DX camera?