Can I get sharper results than a pinhole camera for multi-month film exposures?

Asked 6/25/2015

7 views

2 answers

0

I use a homemade film pinhole camera for exposures lasting multiple months. The images are fun, but I’d like better sharpness while still keeping extremely long exposure times. Is diffraction the main limitation with a pinhole, and is there any lens-based approach that would be sharper while still allowing such long exposures?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

1

No, there is no lens design that allows for sharpening a pinhole image. This is because pinhole cameras by definition don't have lenses.

You can replace the pinhole with a lens to get more sharpness with lower f-stops. That's why normal cameras have lenses instead of pinholes.

With a pinhole, the sharpness gets better as the pinhole gets smaller, which also decreases the amount of light getting thru. Eventually as you make the pinhole smaller, diffraction effects dominate and sharpness gets worse again. This is basic physics that you can't get around. Note that diffraction effects are a function of the pinhole size to the wavelength of light. You can get a sharper picture (use a smaller pinhole before diffraction makes sharpness worse) if you are only imaging with blue light, for example.

Originally by user7603. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user7603

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A pinhole is limited by a tradeoff between geometric blur and diffraction. Making the hole smaller usually improves sharpness at first, but once it gets too small diffraction makes the image softer again. So yes, diffraction is one of the main limits, and there is an optimal pinhole diameter for a given focal length and wavelength.

To improve a pinhole camera, use the optimal hole size and make sure the hole is very round and cleanly made; a precisely made or laser-drilled pinhole can help. Using larger film can also improve the perceived result.

If you want significantly sharper images, you generally need to replace the pinhole with a lens. A sharp lens plus strong neutral-density filtration can still allow very long exposures while being much sharper than a pinhole. For film, also be aware of reciprocity failure during very long exposures, which can require even longer times and may cause color shifts.

So: no special lens design magically combines pinhole simplicity with much better sharpness at the same tiny aperture, but a real lens with heavy ND filtration is the practical way to get sharper long exposures.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer