Can exposure compensation replace spot metering?
Asked 9/25/2019
5 views
2 answers
0
If I can change exposure with exposure compensation, is spot metering doing anything fundamentally different? In other words, if I know how much brighter or darker I want the image, can I get the same result without using spot metering? Or does spot metering provide information that exposure compensation alone does not?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
8
Is spot metering just an EV compensation?
Metering, regardless of type, and exposure compensation are different functions with different purposes. Metering is used to obtain exposure exposure settings (ISO, aperture, shutter speed), while exposure compensation is used to modify those values. It is basically the difference between nouns and adjectives.
There are typically several metering methods to choose from:
- Average – The entire scene is averaged and compared with some reference (usually middle gray).
- Center weighted – The scene is averaged with emphasis on the center of the frame. (It is given more "weight".) The result is compared with the reference.
- Spot – A small portion of the frame ("spot") is compared with the reference. It usually covers about 1-2% of the frame. In some cameras, it is always the center point. For others, it follows the focus point.
- Evaluative / Matrix / Multi / Etc – These are proprietary methods that vary by make and model. A commonly described method in this group divides the frame into several parts that are evaluated separately. The pattern can be compared with entries in a database to find an appropriate exposure setting.
Exposure compensation takes results from any of the above metering methods and adjusts it to increase (+) or decrease (-) exposure. The amount of compensation to use depends on the desired result and photographers' judgment.
If I spot meter...can I achieve identical results with EV compensation?
While it is possible to obtain the same settings from any of the metering methods by applying an appropriate adjustment, exposure compensation would be determined on a scene-by-scene basis by comparing the settings produced by different exposure modes. There is no single EC setting that will transform results from one metering mode into that of another.
So a photographer that is good with EV adjustments technically wouldn't need spot metering?
Spot metering isn't needed, though some may like to use it. A few cameras have only a single metering mode. On such cameras, exposure compensation is the only way to control exposure.
Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user75526
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Spot metering and exposure compensation are related, but they do different jobs.
Metering decides what exposure the camera thinks is correct. Spot metering does this by reading only a very small area of the frame, instead of averaging a larger area or the whole scene. Exposure compensation then tells the camera to make that metered result brighter or darker than its default recommendation.
So yes: if you already know exactly how much compensation is needed, you can often reach the same final exposure without spot metering. But spot metering helps you determine that in the first place by ignoring parts of the scene you don’t want influencing the reading.
Example: a face in shade against a bright sky. A wider meter pattern may include lots of sky and underexpose the face. Spot metering on the face excludes most of the sky and gives a reading based on the subject. You could mimic that with exposure compensation, but only if you know beforehand how much to adjust.
So a photographer can work without spot metering, especially in manual mode or with experience, but spot metering is a useful tool—not just generic EV compensation.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I intentionally create a bright subject against a dark background outdoors?
Can spot metering errors be fixed in post-processing?
How should I use spot metering, and is it better in manual or priority modes?
Does spot or partial metering treat the metered area as middle gray?
Can I make JPEGs look darker in-camera without increasing noise?