Can I make JPEGs look darker in-camera without increasing noise?
Asked 8/16/2020
4 views
2 answers
0
I want photos to have a darker final look, but when I reduce exposure in-camera (for example with negative exposure compensation), the image gets noisier because less light reaches the sensor. If I instead expose brighter and darken later in post, I get a cleaner result.
Is there a general camera feature that keeps a normal/good exposure for image quality, then applies a digital brightness reduction only when creating the JPEG? I’m asking generally, but my camera is a Canon 80D.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
2
Well, you want a dark look, so you need EV- adjustment. You still want good exposure, so you need low ISO. Some cameras go only down to base ISO, some have "extended" low ISO which actually means that the camera does some of the ETTR mantra while dialing down exposure in its own "postprocessing".
If the lowest settable ISO (whether real or "extended") in connection with the desired value of EV- still has too much noise, then you won't get away without postprocessing on your own for lowering the final amount of brightness.
Originally by user94588. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user94588
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—on many cameras, the way to get a darker JPEG without the extra noise of underexposure is to expose normally (or as far right as you can without clipping highlights) and then use in-camera JPEG processing controls rather than reducing the actual exposure too much.
Key point: making the sensor receive less light increases noise relative to the signal. A darker final look is best created after capture, either in post or via the camera’s JPEG tone/rendering settings.
In general:
- Negative exposure compensation is a physical exposure change, so it can worsen noise.
- Lower ISO helps preserve quality when possible.
- Some cameras offer extended low ISO or JPEG style/tone adjustments that effectively darken the rendered JPEG after capture.
- If your camera’s in-camera processing options are limited, external post-processing gives much more control.
So the general answer is: use enough exposure for good signal-to-noise, then darken the JPEG through in-camera processing if your model supports it. If not, there’s no magic setting that avoids the tradeoff—less light on the sensor means noisier data.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does my RAW-to-JPEG export look noisier than the camera’s JPEG?
Why do RAW files look flatter or darker than camera JPEGs, and how can I match the camera look?
What’s the difference between exposure compensation and Picture Control brightness in-camera?
Why do Lightroom photos sometimes look noisy after export, then look clean again later?
Why doesn’t camera exposure compensation change hot-shoe flash exposure on a Canon XTi?