Can Canon's pop-up optical flash control work with umbrellas or softboxes, or do I need radio triggers?

Asked 8/15/2012

5 views

2 answers

0

My Canon DSLR can trigger off-camera flashes using the built-in pop-up flash. I’ve noticed the remote flash works best when its optical sensor can see the camera’s flash. If I put the flash behind an umbrella or inside/behind a softbox, will the optical wireless system still work, or is a radio trigger system necessary?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

6

Not necessarily.

The sensor on the flash must be able to "see" the triggering flash, but it does not have to be direct light. The 430EX and 580EX both are sensitive enough that bounced flash works equally as well. You simply need to orient the flash sensor so that it can see 'out' from the umbrella, even if that means a convenient wall or other reflector. You will find that you can even put a flash in an adjoining room, as long as there is some ability for your triggering flash to be 'seen' by the slave unit.

For example, this image shows two 430EX flashes, used outdoors. One, being held by the biologic flash stand, has the sensor covered by the biologic flash stand attachment point (hand). The other 430EX is behind the umbrella itself, but can 'see' the triggering flash thru the umbrella and via the reflector. Note that the 430EX sensors are pointing to the side. Also, this is triggered via an ST-E2.

enter image description here

Originally by user4880. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user4880

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

You do not necessarily need radio triggers. Canon’s optical wireless system does not always require a direct, unobstructed line of sight; the slave sensor just needs to detect the triggering light, which can sometimes bounce off nearby walls or pass through/around an umbrella setup. In practice, flashes like the 430EX/580EX can often still fire reliably if you orient the sensor so it can “see out” toward the room or a reflective surface.

That said, with umbrellas, softboxes, and other modifiers, optical triggering can become unreliable and may require awkward flash positioning. Indoors it often works better because of reflected light; outdoors or in less reflective spaces it can be hit-or-miss.

So: optical control can work with modifiers, but radio triggers are often the more reliable choice if you want consistent firing and easier placement. If you rely on TTL, you may still use the camera’s optical system and accept its limitations.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer