Can an off-camera flash overpower daylight in shade, especially through a diffuser?

Asked 8/14/2014

7 views

2 answers

0

I tried an outdoor portrait on a sunny day with my subject under a canopy in shade so the sun wouldn’t be the key light. I wanted the sunlit background to go bright while using an off-camera flash as the key on the subject, with some reflector fill.

I was shooting around 1/200s and using a Sony HVL-F43AM at full power, first through an umbrella and then bare, but it still seemed weak compared with the ambient light. I later realized the flash was roughly 15 feet from the subject.

So I’m trying to understand whether my approach is sound: can a speedlight realistically compete with daylight outdoors, particularly in shade, and how much do distance, shutter speed, and diffusion affect that? Also, is a higher-guide-number speedlight roughly in the same output class as a monolight once both are used through light modifiers?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

5

Compete with sunlight? Sure, easily, especially in shade. My 600EX-RT through a small soft box is still sufficient to compete with sunlight and give primary lighting from the flash if I want it to. The key is to a) be close enough and b) shoot fast enough.

A flash is not sustained light, it is very intense light for a very short time. The longer your exposure, the more time ambient light has to accumulate on the sensor. Shorter exposures give your flash a higher degree of influence. When you hit the HSS point for your camera, you will lose a fair bit of power, but it may still work out to be worth it for the extra shutter speed you can get to reduce the ambient further as well.

Adding additional flashes to the setup makes it even easier to accomplish, allowing shooting from further away or will slower shutter speeds (though still pretty fast).

I'm not sure what you mean by blowing the background. That normally means it would be all white, which doesn't makes any sense in this case. To blow the background to white, you simply would over-expose the background and wouldn't want flash. If you meant you want the background to be black, that also doesn't make any sense as you would have to be many (6+ at least) stops brighter than the ambient light for the time exposed, which is an insane amount of light, far, far beyond trying to simply compete with sunlight.

From your update, being 15 feet away is certainly a big part of the problem. That's forever away during outdoor shots. You basically want the flash as close as you can get without being a) in frame or b) casting undesirably hard shadows. Light power falls off exponentially over distance, so the closer you can get, the more power you have.

Also note that if you can't completely blow the background without the flash, you really aren't going to be able to do it with the flash because the flash is adding light to the foreground which means that exposure of the background will go down, making it less blown.

Originally by user11392. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user11392

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—an off-camera flash can compete with daylight, especially if your subject is in shade. The main issues in your test were distance and exposure balance.

A flash’s effective power drops very quickly with distance, so having it about 15 feet away severely reduces its impact. Bringing the light much closer is often more important than buying a somewhat stronger flash. Diffusers and umbrellas also cut output.

For outdoor flash portraits, first set the ambient exposure for the background you want, then add flash for the subject. If you want the background bright or blown out, that’s mostly controlled by your ambient exposure, not the flash. If instead you want the flash to dominate more, use a faster shutter speed up to sync speed; beyond that, HSS can help reduce ambient, though it also lowers flash power.

So yes, speedlights can work outdoors in shade, but success depends heavily on flash-to-subject distance, modifier losses, and shutter speed. If you need more reach or larger modifiers, adding more flashes or moving up to a monolight can help.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer