Can an EF-S lens be used on a full-frame Canon body with an extension tube?
Asked 11/22/2013
3 views
2 answers
0
EF-S lenses normally aren’t compatible with Canon full-frame DSLRs. If an extension tube physically moves the lens farther from the mirror, can that make it usable, or are there still problems such as vignetting, loss of infinity focus, or loss of camera communication?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
2
It isn't just the possibility of the mirror impacting, it is also the size of the image circle projected. While an extension tube moves the lens away (and thus will make the image circle a little bigger in some cases) it's still going to have all the extension tube caveats. You would likely also have to shoot full manual as the camera probably isn't going to detect or allow electrical connection to an EF-s lens with which it isn't compatible.
Even if the extension tube fakes it for you, auto-focus with an extension tube can be pretty dicey. As Michael Nielsen mentioned, you will almost certainly lose the ability to focus to infinity (though you will also reduce the minimum focus distance).
You would also want to make sure it was a long enough extension tube before trying it. A short extension tube may still not clear the mirror if the optics extend out of the back of the lens at some part of the zoom.
Originally by user11392. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user11392
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Not as a practical general solution. An extension tube may create enough physical clearance in some cases, but it does not fix the main optical limitation: EF-S lenses project a smaller image circle than full-frame sensors need, so you’ll usually see heavy dark corners or a tunnel effect.
An extension tube also changes how the lens focuses. You will lose infinity focus and push the lens into close-up/macro range, while reducing minimum working distance. That can be useful for creative macro shooting, but not for normal full-frame use.
There may also be compatibility issues with mounting and electronic communication, and autofocus with extension tubes is often unreliable anyway.
So yes, in limited cases you might get an image for close-up work and crop away the dark edges, but no, it’s not a good way to make an EF-S lens function like a normal lens on a full-frame camera.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do extension tubes reduce maximum focus distance and enable closer focusing?
Can Canon EF lenses be adapted to a Pentax 645N, and will they cover the full 645 frame?
Do Nikon extension tubes with electronic contacts work with E-type lenses?
Why doesn’t a Canon EF-to-Sony E adapter act like an extension tube?
Can you use a Canon EF macro lens on a Nikon F body as an extension tube for close-up work?