Can a split diopter bring two different optical path lengths into focus in one shot?

Asked 6/23/2019

2 views

2 answers

0

I’m doing fixed-position high-speed scientific imaging with a Micro Nikkor 105mm lens. The camera sees a subject directly from the side, and also from below via a small mirror at 45° under the subject. Because the mirror view has a different optical path length, I can’t get both the side view and underside view sharp at the same time.

Would placing a small convex lens in only one part of the image path—so that one view passes through it before entering the camera lens, while the other view does not—allow both views to be in focus at once? If so, what kind of lens/filter is this, and what math is typically used to estimate the needed optical power?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

5

Cinematography solved this problem long ago with the split diopter. It's literally just half of a screw-on diopter, just like so-called "close up filter" (although it doesn't filter anything, it's called that because it mounts to the lens like other front-mounted actual filters).

split diopter

Split diopters don't see much use in photography, but they used to be used in film a lot, when the director wanted to draw the viewer's focus simultaneously to a near subject and a far subject. They're still used in film, but with today's CGI and compositing, the effect is now usually done in software with multiple takes, rather than in-camera in the same shot.

This article talks about several classic cinema shots achieved with split diopters.

split-diopter shot from _All The President's Men_
split-diopter shot from All The President's Men

split-diopter shot from _Jaws_ split-diopter shot from Jaws

Originally by user11924. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user11924

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. What you’re describing is essentially a split diopter: a partial close-up lens placed over only part of the taking lens so one region of the frame is focused at a different distance than the rest. This has long been used in cinematography to keep near and far subjects sharp in the same shot.

The added lens changes the focus for only the portion of the image passing through it, so in principle it can compensate for the different optical path length of your mirror view.

The usual starting point is the same math as for front-mounted close-up lenses. These are often specified in diopters. As a simple approximation, optical power and focus distance are related by:

focus distance (m) ≈ 1 / diopters

So a +8 diopter lens corresponds to about 0.125 m when the main lens is focused at infinity. Your case is more complicated because the main lens will not necessarily be at infinity focus, but diopter calculations are still the right framework.

Search for split diopters or close-up diopter lenses, then test the needed strength experimentally for your geometry.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer