Can a Sony HVL-F36AM flash be used wirelessly with a Nikon D7000?
Asked 4/17/2011
3 views
2 answers
0
I have a Nikon D7000 and a Sony HVL-F36AM flash from an older Sony Alpha 100. Can this Sony flash be used in wireless mode with the Nikon D7000, or are the two systems incompatible?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
2
The answer is: no, this won't work.
But it's not because Sony actively is blocking the flash from working. It's just that Nikon's wireless TTL system (which they call "CLS" — Creative Lighting System) isn't compatible with Sony's wireless TTL protocol, which they call "WL" (presumably for WireLess). The concept is the same — a measurement preflash, and then the control flash on the camera sends a digitally-encoded optical signal telling the slaves how much power to use and when to fire. But the implementation of the signal is different (and proprietary), so the two brands can't talk to each other. The same is true with Canon, Pentax, and Olympus's wireless flash systems.
The Sony flash's wireless capabilities are limited to this WL system; it does not have non-TTL "digital slave" mode, so you can't use it that way either. (If it did, you could set flash power manually and still get basic wireless functionality.)
However, you could spend some money and get a radio-based third party wireless trigger system like the Pocketwizard , which you can hook to the flash with an adapter. Many people find the radio systems superior to the optical built-in systems, but for a wide variety of cases the built-in systems are great. (Less bulk, and of course less to buy, and TTL operation, which is available through the higher-price radios but not the budget ones.)
Nikon's CLS flash lineup is excellent (and widely regarded as the best optical TTL slave system). So, while the bad news is that you probably can't easily make great use of your existing flash, the good news is that you won't go wrong in the new system.
Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1943
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
No. The Sony HVL-F36AM will not work as a wireless TTL flash with a Nikon D7000.
The issue is not that Sony is deliberately blocking it; Nikon and Sony simply use different proprietary optical wireless TTL systems. Nikon’s CLS and Sony’s WL both use preflashes and encoded optical control signals, but the signaling format is different, so they cannot communicate with each other. This is generally true across brands.
Based on the provided answers, the HVL-F36AM’s wireless function is limited to Sony’s WL system and does not offer a generic non-TTL optical slave mode that would make cross-brand wireless use possible.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can Sony wireless TTL optical flash triggering be used with simple optical slave flashes?
Is the Godox XPro trigger compatible with the Hähnel Viper flash system?
What wireless flash options work with a Sony A200 and HVL-F58AM?
How can I set up low-key photography with a Sony A57 and HVL-43 flash?
Will Nikon Series E and AI-S lenses work on a Nikon D7000?