Can a monitor’s sRGB mode or factory ICC profile substitute for hardware calibration?

Asked 5/1/2020

2 views

2 answers

0

I don’t have a colorimeter, but I’d still like reasonably accurate color while editing photos. I have two standard-gamut monitors:

  1. One has a manufacturer-supplied ICC profile that Windows installed automatically.
  2. The other has an sRGB mode and came with a factory calibration report claiming low Delta-E in that mode; when enabled, brightness and contrast are locked.

Can either of these be used as a decent temporary substitute for hardware calibration?

Specifically:

  • Is a generic manufacturer ICC profile useful for getting colors into the right ballpark, or is it little better than no profile?
  • If I use a monitor’s sRGB mode, should I still set the display profile in the OS to sRGB?
  • What is the practical purpose of a manufacturer ICC profile if it is not individually measured for my exact panel?
  • Does using sRGB mode help even for color-managed editing, or is it mainly for taming wide-gamut behavior in non-color-managed apps?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

1

Can I use “sRGB mode” or a manufacturer's ICC-profile as a poor substitute for hardware calibration?

You could, but that's exactly what it would be – a poor substitute. Generic manufacturer profiles will not be able to compensate for a specific device's idiosyncrasies. It may be "off" from the factory. It may develop color shifts over time. It may not work well with your video card or software. Etc.

I have no colourimeter to perform hardware calibration, but... I know ... to get the screen colours to show up correctly you need to calibrate the screen.

A popular shopping site currently has multiple listings for colorimeters ~$35. – "Just try it. What do you have to lose?"

... would applying the manufacturer-supplied ICC-profile provide colours that are in the right ballpark? Why or why not? Does theory deviate from practice here and why? ... does setting the sRGB-profile provide a semi-adequate sRGB gamut output for the monitor?

No one knows without comparing to a reference, such as a colorimeter, which you appear averse to using.

... what colour setting does the monitor need to be set through the OSD-interface using the buttons on the monitor itself (or through DDC)? ... what is the purpose of a manufacturer-supplied ICC-profile? ... what happens internally when using the screen's "sRGB mode"?

These are device dependent. Consider referring to the manual or contacting the manufacturers.

The second display does not have a manufacturer-supplied ICC-profile, although it has a "sRGB mode". The monitor came with a calibration report, indicating that in sRGB its delta-E is lower than 2.

Depending on your needs, you may not need perfect calibration. Assuming no significant color shifts, your "second display" may be good enough since it seems to have been individually calibrated by the manufacturer.

Suppose you are on a trip and you don't have access to a computer set up for colour management and you still really need to make some adjustments.

If you bring your own devices with you (eg, laptop), they will not decalibrate themselves simply because you are traveling. You could also edit on an iPhone or iPad, and results may be good enough since many people consume content on their phones and tablets.

You could make some basic display adjustments, but they don't ensure color accuracy. Computers at hotel "business centers" are usually locked down to prevent configuration of display settings and installation of photo editing software.

See:

Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user75526

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

As a temporary workaround, yes—but it’s still only a rough substitute for real calibration.

A generic manufacturer ICC profile is usually only an average for that model, not your exact unit. Monitors vary from sample to sample, can drift over time, and may behave differently with your graphics card/software. So it may be somewhat helpful, but often it’s not much better than no custom calibration.

Of your two options, the monitor with a dedicated sRGB mode is the more trustworthy choice. A locked sRGB mode and a factory report suggest the display is constraining itself to a known target, which is useful. In that case, you should still set the display profile in the OS to sRGB so color-managed apps know how to interpret the screen.

What sRGB mode does internally is typically restrict the monitor’s native behavior to approximate the sRGB standard, often by fixing brightness/contrast and other controls to preserve that calibration.

Bottom line: sRGB mode + sRGB profile is the better stopgap. A factory ICC profile may get you “in the ballpark,” but neither approach matches calibrating your specific monitor with a colorimeter.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer