Can a modern hot-shoe flash safely be used on an older film camera?

Asked 9/28/2014

5 views

2 answers

0

I know older flashes can have high trigger voltages that may damage some modern DSLRs. What about the reverse situation: mounting a modern speedlight on an older mechanical or film camera from decades ago? Is that generally safe because the flash’s trigger voltage is low, or could the older camera still be damaged? If there is a problem, is it usually just that the flash may not trigger or sync properly at the camera’s flash sync speed?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

16

The trigger voltage you are worrying about doesn't come from the camera; it's all in the flash. All the camera does, in effect, is "flip a switch"; it shorts out the centre pin of the flash and the contacts at the side of the flash's foot.

The voltage problem comes from the kind of "switch" used to short out those contacts. In (most) modern cameras, that "switch" is actually a transistor (part of a chip). That transistor can't handle a lot of voltage or current without overheating and burning out. If the voltage is high enough, it can go right through the "off" state of the transistor almost as if it were a straight wire (which it definitely isn't), so the transistor, the chip it's on, and the components around it can be destroyed simply by turning the flash on while it's mounted to the camera — there's no need to actually use the flash to cause the damage.

Older flashes were a lot simpler. There is a capacitor used to store a lot of electrical charge at a voltage that's high enough to arc across the flash tube once the arc is "lit". That's usually something around 300 volts or so (give or take 150 volts). That's a lot, but it's not enough to get the arc started. For that, you need a much higher voltage (usually about 4000 volts). That 4kv trigger voltage was usually gotten by sending the 300v through a small transformer. Your camera contained the switch for that circuit; the moment that 4000 volts was present, the arc would be "lit" and the 300 volt charge would keep it going. (For the technically inclined, there was almost no current in the 4kv circuit; it just went to the equivalent of a teeny-tiny capacitor that would reach full charge almost instantly. It was just the presence of the potential that was required to light the arc. Similarly, the 300v side of the circuit only had to create the leading edge of a potential change on its side of the transformer, so it could be fed from a small capacitor that dumped all of its charge quickly through the primary. There wasn't enough charge to cause any damage to people, and the potential was below the "I think I felt a shock" threshold of about 600v.) The switch in your camera back then was a real, physical mechanical switch hooked up to the shutter.

Modern flashes contain all of the high-voltage stuff too, but they keep it to themselves. The camera is only required to short out a low-voltage circuit (usually under 6 volts), which the transistors can handle no sweat, and that's used to trigger the high voltage circuit inside the flash. Your old camera will be able to trigger a modern flash reliably and safely; it's only the old-flash-on-a-modern-camera scenario that's dangerous.

As long as your camera has X sync, the flash will sync properly. Very old cameras may not have an X sync, which is meant for electronic flash; they may have an M sync instead (which is meant for flashbulbs, and fires earlier to give the bulb a chance to heat up a bit before the shutter is fully open), or they may have both X and M sync terminals and you have to make sure you're connected to the right terminal. The sync speed only determines the fastest shutter speed you can use with the flash, it (almost always) has no effect otherwise. (There are a few cameras that won't sync at all except at the sync speed, and others that won't do TTL/OTF except at sync.)

Originally by user32334. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user32334

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Generally, yes: a modern flash with a low trigger voltage is usually safe on an older film or mechanical camera. The trigger-voltage risk comes from the flash, not the camera. The camera’s hot shoe or PC socket mainly just closes a switch to fire the flash.

The usual danger is the opposite case: an old flash with high trigger voltage damaging a modern camera, because modern cameras often use delicate electronic switching circuits. Older mechanical cameras typically use simpler, more robust contacts.

With a modern speedlight on an older camera, the main limitations are compatibility and sync behavior, not damage. The flash should fire if the center pin and ground are standard, but advanced features such as TTL metering, dedicated communication, zoom control, or high-speed sync usually will not work unless the camera and flash were designed for each other. In many cases the flash will only work in basic manual or auto-thyristor mode.

You still need to use the camera’s proper X-sync shutter speed or slower to avoid partial-frame exposure issues.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer