Can a crop-sensor zoom lens cover a larger sensor at some focal lengths?

Asked 7/31/2012

8 views

2 answers

0

Do zoom lenses made for APS-C/DX always project the same small image circle, or can the image circle change as you zoom? For example, could an APS-C zoom like a 16-85mm cover more than APS-C at some focal lengths, and would that let a full-frame camera stop cropping when the lens is zoomed in far enough? If an APS-C lens did fully cover full frame at 24mm or longer, would its angle of view at 24mm simply be the normal full-frame 24mm view?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

8

On some lenses the image circle does indeed get bigger as you zoom.

I know from experience the Canon EF-S 10-22 f/3.5-4.5 does this. At 12mm the image circle is big enough for a 1.3x crop APS-H sized sensor and by 15mm it is big enough for a full frame 35mm sensor.

However lenses such as the EF-S 17-55 f/2.8 vignette at all focal lengths on full frame. I believe the constant max aperture has something to do with it, as otherwise the total amount of light coming out of the lens would somehow change despite the iris and entrance pupil remaining the same size.

Note that the reverse is not necessarily true, the image circle doesn't necessarily get larger with a variable max aperture lens. Some Nikon lenses contain a rear baffle to reduce flare, and this causes the same vignetting regardless of focal length. Integral petal hoods on ultra-wides can have the same effect.

Finally, assuming the DX 16-85mm does not vignette on full frame at 24mm, it will have the same angle of view as any other 24mm lens - 73.7 degrees horizontally and 53.1 degree vertically.

Conditional cropping based on focal length would produce a very strange relationship between focal length and angle of view with the lens getting wider then narrower as you zoom in!

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

No—an APS-C zoom lens does not necessarily keep the same image circle throughout its zoom range, but it also does not necessarily grow enough to cover full frame.

It depends on the specific optical design. Some crop-format zooms do project a larger image circle as they zoom, and may partially or fully cover a bigger sensor at longer focal lengths. Others vignette on full frame at every focal length. Mechanical features like rear baffles can also limit coverage regardless of zoom position.

So a camera cannot assume that every DX/APS-C lens will cover full frame past some focal length unless that behavior is known for that exact lens.

If a crop lens does fully cover a full-frame sensor at a given focal length, then its angle of view is simply the angle of view of that focal length on full frame. In other words, 24mm would behave like 24mm on full frame—not like 24mm on APS-C—provided the image circle actually covers the whole sensor with acceptable vignetting and image quality.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer