Can a Canon 500D still compete with a modern smartphone, or should I upgrade on a €200 budget?
Asked 5/27/2019
3 views
2 answers
0
I’m returning to photography after a break and still have a Canon EOS 500D with the kit lens. Comparing its photos to modern smartphones makes the DSLR seem disappointing, especially in low light. I was considering buying a used lens, but I’m worried the camera’s older sensor may be the limiting factor. I mostly shoot family and landscape photos at a slow pace, often in low light, and my budget is about €200 second-hand. Is it worth improving the 500D with a used lens, or are current smartphones simply better for this kind of photography?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
30
The overall difference in typical image quality between a current smartphone like the Huawei P30 Pro and an older DSLR like the Canon EOS Rebel T1i/500D isn't the difference between the sensors. The difference is about who makes the decisions when shooting and, more importantly, in post processing about how both are done.
Recent smartphones have gotten very good at computational photography. Sometimes they even take multiple exposures and use AI to either select the best of several frames or computationally combine the multiple frames into a single image. To use an older, or even more current, DSLR or mirrorless interchangeable lens camera to do the same type of computational photography requires the user to do things and make decisions that the smartphones are automatically doing under the surface.
One must decide, for example, how many frames to take in quick succession. Should they all be at the same exposure level or bracketed? Should they all be at the same focus distance or bracketed? Should exposure be based upon the brightest highlights in the scene? Or the darkest shadows? The options are multiplied even more when processing the image data from the sensor to produce a viewable image. A highly skilled post processor can get a lot out of even fairly poor, by 2019 standards, sensors if the image was exposed properly. Learning how to expose properly in challenging light is an art that takes a lot of time and effort to learn. It also takes a lot of knowledge, skill, and experience to be able to post process better than modern AI routines included in smartphones and, to a lesser extent, digital cameras.
For most folks who only do casual photography, it's not worth the time and effort to learn how to do it themselves with a dedicated camera instead of letting the programmed routines of a smartphone do it for them.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes, your 500D can still be worth using. The main reason modern phones often look better straight away is not that their sensors are “twice as good,” but that phones do heavy computational photography automatically: multi-frame HDR, noise reduction, sharpening, and scene optimization. DXOMARK mobile and camera scores are also not directly comparable, so the phone’s higher number does not mean it has a better sensor in a simple one-to-one sense.
For about €200, the most useful upgrade is likely a used fast prime lens, such as a 50mm f/1.8 or possibly f/1.4. That can improve low-light shooting and give you true shallow depth of field that phones usually simulate.
Your DSLR still offers a larger sensor than a phone, interchangeable lenses, and better handling. A smartphone may still win for convenience and automatic processing, especially if you want ready-to-share images with no effort. But for image quality potential, especially with a better lens and careful editing, the 500D is far from obsolete.
Best advice: do a side-by-side test with your camera and a current phone, then compare the files on a computer at full resolution.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Are budget compact cameras better than flagship smartphones for point-and-shoot photos?
Is it normal for autofocus to miss focus in low light on a Sony NEX-5R?
Good resources for getting back into photography in the digital era
Can Magic Lantern show the wrong shutter count on a Canon 500D?
Best camera under $350 for newborn photos in low light and 11x15 prints