Are wireless flash trigger systems compatible across brands?

Asked 6/23/2013

1 views

2 answers

0

I’m moving from wired to wireless off-camera flash and I’m confused about compatibility. Some flashes and triggers mention things like “channel 1, group A,” and some flashes have built-in receivers. If I’m only using manual flash power—not TTL—are radio trigger systems standardized across manufacturers, or are they proprietary? For example, can a transmitter from one brand trigger a receiver from another brand just because they use the same channel/group terms or radio frequency? How can I tell what is actually compatible before buying?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

5

It's all proprietary, I'm afraid, and interoperability is pretty much in-brand when it's there at all. (Though you may expect third-party makers to a least try compatibility with Canon's RF system at some point.) Some pro-level equipment is compatible with the PocketWizard system, or at least versions of it, but that seems to be licensed. (I'm sure the good folks at PocketWizard have nothing against convenience, but they'd probably just as soon you bought another of their units rather than simply copy their signalling system. Oh, and you wouldn't be able to say you're "PocketWizard compatible" without violating their trademarks either.)

As for the cheaper RF triggers/receivers, the compatibility is pretty much within a model range. Cactus V5 triggers, for instance, are not compatible with V4s, which are not compatible with V3s, and so on. It's the same situation with Yongnuo and Phottix -- unless they tell you that different units are compatible (usually with a common "name" for the range of devices), they won't be. Frequencies vary (newer units tend to work in the 2.4GHz band, while older ones are in the 900MHz range), as do signal encoding schemes and so forth. At the low end of the market, there's no real requirement to protect the users' investment in your old technology.

Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2719

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Usually no—wireless flash trigger systems are generally proprietary, and compatibility is typically limited to the same brand or even the same model family.

Terms like “channel” and “group” are not a universal standard. Different makers can use the same words while using completely different signaling protocols. Even units on the same radio frequency are often not interoperable.

If TTL is involved, compatibility gets even narrower because TTL protocols are camera-system specific. In manual mode, some cross-compatibility may exist in limited cases, but you should not assume that a transmitter from one brand will trigger a receiver from another.

There are exceptions: some systems support compatibility within a product line, and some professional gear supports PocketWizard-compatible versions by design or license. But in general, buy triggers and receivers that are explicitly listed as working together.

Best practice: research the exact transmitter, receiver, and flash models you want to combine, and check the manufacturer’s compatibility information or reliable flash/lighting compatibility guides before purchasing.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer