Are there drawbacks or compatibility issues with using LZW-compressed TIFFs for editing and archiving?

Asked 5/9/2020

4 views

2 answers

0

I’m editing smartphone JPEG photos in GIMP and plan to save working files as 8-bit RGB TIFFs. I may crop and adjust tones with Curves, then export final JPEGs for my blog while keeping the TIFFs on my computer and an external drive for future use.

I understand that LZW compression makes TIFF files smaller than uncompressed TIFFs. Aside from smaller file size, are there any other advantages? Are there any limitations, technical risks, or compatibility problems to be aware of when using LZW-compressed TIFFs for editing and long-term storage?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

4

For me the benefits can be:

  • less disk space (compressed data)
  • less time to load (but plus time to decompress)
  • same for write

But I will have in mind few negative points:

  • compatibility, it's possible not all programs understand this TIFF format and can load it
  • one (of few) bit error(s) can ruin most of the image (because of the compression string)
  • disk/cloud space is so cheap

And at the end depend of bottleneck of your computer compressed files can save faster (or the opposite)

Originally by user34947. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user34947

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The main benefit of LZW in TIFF is lossless size reduction: the image data stays the same, but the file takes less storage space. Depending on your system, smaller files can also sometimes read or write faster, though compression/decompression adds processing time, so speed can go either way.

Possible drawbacks:

  • Compatibility: some software may not fully support every TIFF compression variant, so LZW TIFFs can be less universally compatible than uncompressed TIFFs.
  • Corruption sensitivity: with compressed data, a bit error can potentially affect a larger part of the image than with uncompressed data.
  • Performance varies: if your computer is CPU-limited rather than storage-limited, compressed files may save/load more slowly.

So yes, LZW is generally useful for saving space without losing image quality, but it’s not automatically better in every workflow. If your software supports it reliably, it’s usually fine for editing and storage; if maximum compatibility is important, uncompressed TIFF may be safer.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer