Are smartphone camera lenses lower quality than DSLR or compact camera lenses, and why?

Asked 6/11/2015

6 views

2 answers

0

People often say phone camera lenses are "inferior" to those in DSLRs or compact cameras. Is that actually true? If so, what makes smartphone lenses different, and how much of the image quality difference comes from the lens versus the sensor?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

5

The lenses in mobile phones are typically made from molded plastic elements rather than ground glass elements, and these are in optically inferior to glass in general (higher dispersion, lower refractive indices). However molded elements have a big advantage in that they can be made into absolutely any shape, whereas glass is very difficult to grind into anything other than a sphere. Highly sophisticated designs thus are possible with every element being ashperical (high end DSLR lenses typically have only one or two aspherical elements).

Mobile phone camera lenses are in some ways better than DSLR lenses in that their resolution in terms of line pairs per millimeter is higher. But the sensors they are used with are so small that the total resolution across the image is lower. They also have to be faster (wider maximum aperture) to avoid diffraction, attempting to achieve the total image resolution of the best DSLR system is simply beyond the capabilities of the materials, given the size of phone cameras - which is the ultimate limiting factor.

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Smartphone lenses are often different rather than simply “bad.” Many phone lenses use molded plastic elements instead of ground glass. Plastic is generally optically less ideal than glass, but it also allows complex aspherical shapes that are hard to make in glass, so phone lenses can be highly optimized in a very small package.

A phone lens may even have very high resolution in line pairs per millimeter, but it only has to cover a tiny sensor. The much bigger reason smartphones trail DSLRs is sensor size, not just lens quality. A DSLR sensor is vastly larger than a phone sensor, so it gathers much more light and can deliver better overall image quality.

So yes, phone lenses are often built with different materials and design tradeoffs, but the main limitation compared with DSLRs is the tiny sensor. Even an excellent lens on a small phone sensor would still not match the image quality of a large-sensor camera.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer