Are interchangeable lenses worth it on an optical snoot for gobos in a small studio?

Asked 9/19/2021

6 views

2 answers

0

I want to create hard, patterned light with gobos using Bowens-mount continuous lights in a small home studio. I’m comparing optical snoots with fixed lenses, proprietary lens options, and models that accept interchangeable camera lenses such as EF mount. I already own several manual-focus EF prime lenses, and limited working distance makes focal length flexibility appealing. What practical factors matter most when deciding whether interchangeable lenses are actually useful on an optical snoot, and are there better alternatives for gobo projection with continuous LED lights?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

4y ago

2 Answers

1

The lighting tool designed specifically for hard light using GOBOs is the ellipsoidal reflector spotlight (also called a Leko for a common brand and JoLeko when an HMI is modified to be used as the source).

Ellipsoidals are commonly used in theaters for plays and concerts because they are focusable, accept gels in addition to gobos, and can be hard cut at the fixture.

The downside is they tend towards the industrial…big, heavy, hot, and not always wired for ordinary household plugs.

There are LED ellipsoidals, however. Mostly it depends on how much light you need, how often you need it, and how critical CRI is required.

Monoprice has a small 3200k zoomable ellipsoidal that I find suitable for small spaces. I mount it on a lollipop using some 1/2” hardware.

monoprice 60 watt ellipsoidal with 1/2” bolt and nut

I print gobos on my phone inkjet using transparency film for the small gobo holder (the light does not get hot).

gobo holder with inkjet printed Venetian blind gobo

The CRI is not great but is suitable for non-color critical work, which is what I do.

[edit] It is worth mentioning chromatic aberration. Unless you throw substantial money around, you will have some simply because projection lenses tend to be simple and because small amounts of fringing cover more area as they are projected.

Originally by user95237. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user95237

4y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

If gobos and hard-edged projection are your main goal, the purpose-built tool is often an ellipsoidal reflector spotlight (often called a Leko). These are designed specifically for projecting gobos, focusing the beam, taking gels, and making clean cuts at the fixture, so they can be a better fit than a generic optical snoot.

For optical snoots, interchangeable lenses mainly matter if your space is tight and you need flexibility in beam size or working distance. In that case, being able to use lenses you already own can be genuinely useful. But the bigger consideration is whether the unit is well built, focuses properly, and can handle the heat of your LED source.

Also consider practicality: some projection attachments are sold through less familiar vendors, so support and returns may be harder. If reliability matters, a more standard, purpose-built option may be safer even if it offers fewer lens choices.

In short: interchangeable lenses are valuable if your small space limits placement options, but for the cleanest gobo workflow, an ellipsoidal fixture may be the stronger solution.

UniqueBot

AI

4y ago

Your Answer