Are Instagram's basic editing tools the same as Photoshop or Lightroom adjustments?
Asked 5/17/2016
1 views
2 answers
0
I usually shoot JPEG on a Canon DSLR and post to Instagram. For convenience, I often use Instagram's in-app sliders for things like brightness, contrast, saturation, and exposure.
Are these basic adjustments essentially the same across apps, or does each program apply them differently? For example, would contrast or saturation edited in Photoshop or Lightroom look noticeably different from the same-looking adjustment made in Instagram? Also, can some software reduce image quality more than others when making edits, especially when working from JPEG rather than raw files?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
10y ago
2 Answers
3
It depends on what type of file you are editing with Photoshop or Lightroom. Those applications handle raw files in a totally different way than they handle jpegs, pngs, or even tiffs.
The biggest difference between editing a jpeg using photoshop and editing it with most online editors is the degree of control over the adjustments. You will likely not only have finer gradations of control but wider extremes as well. Instead of a single hue and saturation control you can adjust the hue, saturation, and luminance independently for eight different color bands ranging from red, orange, yellow, and green, to aqua, blue purple, and magenta. You can use more sophisticated noise reduction with more user controlled variables. You can draw your own gamma curves instead of only adjusting for contrast and perhaps highlights and shadows.
But to get the full power and functionality of Photoshop, Lightroom (both use Adobe Camera Raw to process raw files, they just differ in the way the interface with ACR works), and other such applications you need to bring the raw file with all of the information collected by your camera's sensor.
When you save your files as jpegs most of how the photo will look is pretty well baked in. A high percentage of the raw data from the sensor is discarded and there is no way to recover it from the resulting jpeg file. At that point most of your editing options are to take away some of the information you have left. This is fundamentally different from editing a raw file in which you may discard some information from the interpretation of the data you see on your screen, but you also have the option to add information from the raw data that is not used in the initial depiction on your screen. You have as much flexibility with regard to color temperature, white balance, contrast, black point, white point, saturation, etc. as the sensor on your camera can record and which the application you are using can take advantage.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
10y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Not exactly. Basic controls like brightness, contrast, saturation, and exposure exist in many apps, but each program uses its own algorithms, so the results can differ.
Photoshop and Lightroom generally offer much more control than Instagram-style editors. For example, instead of one global saturation slider, you may be able to adjust hue, saturation, and luminance separately for multiple color ranges, use custom curves, and apply more advanced noise reduction.
File type matters too. Photoshop and Lightroom handle raw files very differently from JPEG, PNG, or TIFF. Editing a raw file usually gives you more flexibility and better image quality than editing a JPEG, because JPEG already has processing and compression baked in.
With JPEGs, repeated edits and re-saving can reduce quality more than a nondestructive workflow. Simpler mobile or online editors may also give you less precise control, even if the adjustment names are similar.
So: the tools are conceptually similar, but they are not identical in how they work or in the quality and control they provide.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI10y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I recreate Instagram’s Lux-style look in photo editing software?
Which edits are truly RAW-specific, and how do they differ from Photoshop adjustments?
Does the order of Camera Raw adjustments affect the final image?
In Lightroom, is increasing Contrast the same as lowering Highlights and raising Shadows?
Why do NEF raw files look different in Windows Photos, Photo Viewer, and Photoshop?