Are expensive circular polarizer filters worth it compared to cheap ones?

Asked 3/2/2012

2 views

2 answers

0

I already have a circular polarizer for my Canon EF-S 18-55mm. It works, but image quality drops a bit compared to shooting without the filter. I'm considering buying a better CPL, such as a Hoya, along with some ND filters. Do higher-end filters really make a noticeable difference, and are they worth paying more for?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

13

Absolutely, the best ones are worth every penny. While I cannot say I tried every polarizer out there, I tried over a dozen and kept the 4 best ones.

My favorite by far is the Hoya HD Circular Polarizer which lets one full stop more light than every other polarizer. This is an import advantage since more light lets you shoot at lower ISOs and faster shutter-speeds.

Keep in mind that Hoya makes all grades of filters not just the best ones. Even the lowest quality one is not bad but paying more makes a difference. They have 5 quality levels and the Super Multi-Coated one is very good too but does not match the HD's transmittance.

Originally by user1620. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1620

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—better CPLs can be worth it. A polarizer sits directly in the optical path, so poor glass or weak coatings can reduce image quality, contrast, and light transmission more than necessary. Community experience here says higher-quality filters from reputable brands can perform noticeably better than cheap ones, and some premium CPLs also transmit more light, which helps with shutter speed and ISO.

That said, brand alone isn’t enough: many brands sell multiple quality tiers, so the specific filter line matters. Also be careful with very low-priced marketplace listings, since counterfeit “name-brand” filters do exist.

A practical rule is to match the filter quality to the rest of your setup. Don’t put a poor filter in front of a good lens if image quality matters. Even on a modest lens, a decent midrange or better CPL is usually a safer buy than the cheapest option. The same logic applies to ND filters.

So if you’ve already noticed quality loss from your current cheap CPL, upgrading to a reputable, higher-quality filter is likely worthwhile.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer