Will an extension tube increase magnification on a 105mm macro lens?

Asked 2/27/2014

7 views

2 answers

0

I use a Nikon 105mm macro VR lens that already reaches 1:1 magnification. If I add an extension tube, will it let me go beyond 1:1? Most extension tube guides seem to explain things using 50mm lenses, so I want to know how this applies to a 105mm macro lens specifically.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

2

Well, the principle of extension tubes it to shift the focussing distance range closer : just for the sake of example, instead of say [1m, infinity] you'd get [0.5m, 5m] (because you're shifting the focal plane of your lens farther away of the imaging plane - sensor or film -, but I won't dwell on the optics/maths | EDIT : actually already available here on Photo.SE).

So you can put your lens closer than its "normal" minimum focussing distance, therefore you'll get a higher than 1:1 magnification.

However, there are some points to note (possible issues... or not ?) :

  • depending on the length of the tube you'll lose some light in the process, around 1 stop for ~12mm, 2 stops for ~20mm.
  • the depth of field is reduced also, because you're closer to your subject (if at the same aperture), getting your subject in focus might become tricky (without specific/heavy/inconvenient gear)
  • the gain of minimum focussing distance effect decreases as the focal length increases (less "efficient" on 100mm than on say 50mm)
  • you risk blurring because of camera movement (even very small movement at high magnification ratio, even on a tripod)
  • you risk squishing your subject (if it's an insect) because the distance between your front lens and subject becomes smaller (and see Nick Miners's comment below)
  • on a low quality (low price) tube you may lose AF (although it doesn't really matter for macro...), aperture because the lens contacts are not passed through
  • although no additional glass is involved, using the lens to focus closer than it was intended can degrade iamge quality

Originally by user26278. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user26278

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. An extension tube moves the lens farther from the sensor, which reduces the focusing distance and lets the lens focus closer. On a 105mm macro lens that already reaches 1:1, adding extension will typically let you achieve greater than life-size magnification.

What changes:

  • Higher magnification because you can focus closer
  • Loss of light, so exposure may need compensation
  • Shallower depth of field at the same aperture
  • Reduced or eliminated ability to focus at longer distances while the tube is attached

The reason many examples use 50mm lenses is just that extension is often explained with simpler numbers there. The same principle applies to your 105mm macro lens too.

So if your goal is more magnification for close-up work, an extension tube can help. Just expect less working flexibility, dimmer effective exposure, and very thin depth of field.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer