Will a tiny chip or crack on a lens element affect image quality, and should I use the warranty?

Asked 2/16/2015

2 views

2 answers

0

I recently bought a Canon STM zoom lens and noticed a very small mark that looks like dust at first, but on closer inspection it may be a tiny chip or crack on the lens element around the 55mm position. Cleaning the front of the lens and viewfinder did not remove it.

Image quality does not seem affected so far. How can I tell whether this is likely to matter in real photos? Does it make a difference if the mark is on the front element versus the rear element? Should I try to return or warranty the lens, especially if I’m worried about resale value, or is it usually safe to keep using if there’s no visible effect?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

0

If the mark is on the rear element it may cause additional flare in the lens. You won't notice it except when taking photographs toward a bright light source in or near the field of view. In any case though the number of lens surfaces in this design is probably quite large (it's a zoom lens!) so one would expect some flare in any case. Should this prospect bother you (directly or as a possible resale difficulty) then by all means return the lens for a replacement.

If on the other hand the defect is on the front element, it will make no detectable difference. Well, theoretically there may be some flare effect but I'm sure you'd never notice.

See also http://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2008/10/front-element-scratches

Originally by user1359. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1359

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A tiny mark on a lens often matters less than it seems.

If the defect is on the front element, it will usually make no visible difference in normal photos. At most, it could contribute a little flare, but you’d likely never notice it.

If the defect is on the rear element, it has a greater chance of causing flare, especially when shooting toward a bright light source in or near the frame.

So the practical test is simple: take photos in normal conditions and also toward bright light. If you don’t see any effect, it may not be worth worrying about for image quality.

That said, if the lens is new and the mark concerns you, returning or exchanging it is reasonable—particularly for peace of mind or future resale value. The provided answers do not support predicting that a tiny chip will spread into major damage, so image impact is the main concern rather than imminent failure.

In short: front element = usually negligible; rear element = more likely to affect flare; new lens + concern = exchange if possible.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer