Will a larger DSLR viewfinder help with manual focus on vintage lenses?
Asked 12/20/2017
3 views
2 answers
0
I shoot vintage manual-focus lenses on a Canon T3 and often struggle to judge sharp focus through the optical viewfinder, even with good eyesight. I’m considering moving to a Canon 7D, which has a larger, brighter optical viewfinder and uses a pentaprism instead of a pentamirror.
Will a larger/brighter viewfinder make a noticeable difference for manual focusing? Does pentaprism vs. pentamirror matter much? Are there better ways to improve manual-focus accuracy on a DSLR?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
4
Absolutely, yes. But possibly not in the way you're thinking.
The obvious disadvantage is the challenge of getting sharply focuses images while focusing manually. I have great vision, but I still struggle to focus sharply.
You can change the type of focus screen with some dSLR models and that can add some focus aids like split-circles and prism collars; it was one of the many reasons I upgraded to an 50D from a 350D/XT back when Canon still put interchangeable focus screens in the XXDs (before LCD overlays happened). But you still need good eyesight.
Will getting a camera with a larger viewfinder have any appreciable improvement in one's ability to discern focus from what they see in the viewfinder? Will going from pentaprism to pentamirror have any appreciable effect?
A bit. I have a 5DMkII as well as my 50D, and while the 5DMkII has a bigger, brighter viewfinder, and with the precision-matte focus screen, I can actually focus my adapted OM Zuiko 50mm f/1.2 when wide open accurately, since DoF is now depicted accurately. But it's not necessarily a huge amount of difference between that and my 50D equipped with a split/circle prism collar focus screen.
I am looking at a used canon 7D which has a much more magnified viewfinder over the T3 and is pentaprism instead of pentamirror.
The 7D's viewfinder won't be that much larger than the T3's, but it will be a little brighter.
But your best bet is an...
Electronic viewfinder
Mirrorless cameras have electronic viewfinders: ones that show the image the same way the LCD on the back of the camera does. But because it's digital data, the image can be manipulated. Exposure simulation is possible. As are manual focus aids, such as focus peaking, simulated split-screen, and magnification can all be used to help nail manual focus. Both my Fuji X100T and Panasonic GX-7 camera bodies have these types of features, and I find it slightly easier to use them than my alternative viewscreens in my dSLRs to manually focus my adapted manual lenses.
On a Canon dSLR, you can do some of this with the LCD, with the Magic Lantern firmware add-on, but it's not as convenient as having these features in the viewfinder.
Originally by user27440. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user27440
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes, a larger and brighter optical viewfinder can help somewhat with manual focus, and a 7D’s finder is noticeably better than a T3’s. But the improvement is usually incremental rather than dramatic.
The bigger gain is often not pentaprism vs. pentamirror by itself, but overall viewfinder size/magnification and brightness. A pentaprism finder is typically brighter, which can make focusing a bit easier, but don’t expect it to solve manual-focus accuracy on its own.
For many DSLRs, the most effective upgrade is a focusing screen designed for manual focus, such as one with split-prism or microprism aids. Those screens make it much easier to see exact focus, similar to older film SLRs. The tradeoff is that changing the focusing screen can affect metering accuracy, and not every camera supports interchangeable screens.
So: yes, a 7D-style finder should help, but only modestly. If manual focus is a priority, focusing aids or a camera/body setup that supports them will usually make a bigger difference.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Does a brighter pentaprism viewfinder really help with manual focusing on adapted lenses?
Pentaprism vs. pentamirror: what’s the difference in an SLR viewfinder?
How much light does a DSLR focusing screen lose in the optical viewfinder?
What does the pentaprism or pentamirror do in an SLR viewfinder?
Why does my Canon 450D viewfinder feel small, and can I improve it without replacing the camera?