Why won’t Lightroom remove the purple fringe in my photo?
Asked 8/7/2019
3 views
2 answers
0
I’m seeing a purple outline around parts of an image, and Lightroom’s Defringe tool isn’t removing it. I tried the fringe selector and adjusted the sliders, but it still remains. Is this always chromatic aberration, or could it be a different kind of purple fringing that software can’t fully fix?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
3
Purple fringing, also known as longitudinal chromatic aberration, is not the same as lateral chromatic aberration which can easily be compensated for in software (though not fully corrected since each primary color of the sensor spans a range of wavelengths). Lateral chromatic aberration results from different wavelengths of light being projected with slightly different scale to the sensor, typically leading to red/green fringes at the outer parts of the image.
Longitudinal chromatic aberration means that the focus plane for different wavelengths is different. The effect occurs over the entire image and cannot be compensated systematically. Some image processing programs still offer tools to detect and correct such fringes. The typical scenario for purple fringes is sharp edges (such as branches) before the sky. Since the sky contains a high amount of short wavelength visible (and partly UV visible only to the camera) light, the edges may be out of focus for short wavelengths more than for other wavelengths and have purple from the sky bleed over.
Now this may contribute to the basic purple hue you have in your edge, but in your example image there is a lot more going on. It appears like the arm is considerably out of focus and you applied generous amounts of sharpening and likely adaptive noise cancellation. This leads to considerable halos around the edge that also tend to spread out what may have started as a purple fringe from longitudinal chromatic aberration.
Starting from a photograph that is better in-focus will likely make it easier to figure out what is happening, and it might also make some of the image processing corrections be more successful at detecting and masking the fringing.
Originally by user86279. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user86279
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
What you’re likely seeing is purple fringing from longitudinal chromatic aberration, not the more common lateral chromatic aberration that software corrects more easily.
Lateral CA happens when different wavelengths are projected at slightly different sizes, usually causing red/green fringing near the edges of the frame. That type is often reduced well in software.
Purple fringing / longitudinal CA is different: different wavelengths focus at different distances, so the fringe can appear across the image, especially around high-contrast edges. Because it’s tied to focus behavior rather than simple edge displacement, Lightroom’s Defringe tool may not remove it completely.
So yes—this can be a real optical effect that software can only reduce, not fully eliminate. It’s most noticeable on sharp, bright-contrast boundaries and with some lenses/apertures more than others.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How do I manually correct chromatic aberration in Lightroom 4 if the old sliders are gone?
How do Lightroom’s chromatic aberration and Defringe controls work?
How can I remove green and purple fringing from a black-and-white blouse in Lightroom?
Why does purple edge fringing change with ISO and long-exposure noise reduction?
Is strong color fringing at f/1.8 normal on the Pentax DA 50mm f/1.8?