Why don’t infinity-correcting lens adapters use a flat glass window instead of an optical element?

Asked 12/25/2019

4 views

2 answers

0

Some lens adapters restore infinity focus by adding an optical element, often acting like a weak teleconverter. Since a flat piece of optical glass can also shift focus, why aren’t adapters for too-short flange distance made with a thick planar glass window instead? Would a flat glass plate introduce fewer problems, and could this work for unusual adaptations such as relay or X-ray lenses on a DSLR?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

5

Camera lenses are converging lenses, meaning they have positive power. A simple convex lens will do this job, however, the image is flawed. I am talking chromatic aberration whereby each color will come to a focus at a different distance downstream of the lens.

Now a negative lens diverges and a positive lens converges. Additionally they display opposite chromatic aberrations. The lens maker corrects by combining strong positive lens elements with weak negatives. The result is an achromatic (without color error), well nearly but not perfection.

The focal length is a measurement taken when the lens is imaging a far distant target. This will be the shortest back-focus. If the lens and its mounting are mismatched, the infinity focus (the shortest back-focus) may not reach film or digital sensor. To correct, we must somehow shorten the distance lens-to-sensor/film or lengthen the back focus.

The only way to lengthen the back focus is to impose a weak negative (diverging) lens. This procedure actually lengthens the focal length a smidgen. Now a single element negative will do this trick, however, such a lash-up adds to the chromatic aberration.

The countermeasure is a doublet, one with negative power and the other with positive power. The powers are adjusted so the combination has negative power. This is a common trick used in telescopes, called a “Barlow”. This classic supplemental lens array is exactly what is needed to lengthen out a back-focus error.

Incidentally, an optical flat, either before, in-between, or behind the lens elements of a camera lens will microscopically lengthen the focal length so what you propose could be accomplished provided the optical flat was quite thick. Sorry this original post was in error. On with my duce cap, in the corner for two hours.

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A plain flat glass plate can shift focus, but usually not by enough to make a practical adapter. The focus shift produced by parallel glass is smaller than the glass thickness, so to gain the needed extra back-focus distance you’d often need an impractically thick piece of glass—sometimes thicker than the space available in the adapter.

It also doesn’t avoid optical penalties. A flat plate can still introduce image degradation, and once the required correction becomes significant, many of the same problems remain as with an added optical element.

That’s why infinity-correcting adapters typically use a lens element instead: it can produce the needed correction within the limited physical space, even though it often behaves somewhat like a weak teleconverter and may affect image quality.

So for DSLR adaptations where the lens mount is too short, a simple thick window is generally not a successful solution. The same basic limitation would also make it a poor approach for unusual lenses such as relay or X-ray optics unless the required correction were very small.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer