Why don’t cameras always enable high-speed sync automatically above flash sync speed?
Asked 4/2/2021
4 views
2 answers
0
With flash attached, most cameras limit shutter speed to around 1/200s or 1/250s unless high-speed sync (HSS/FP sync) is enabled on the flash system. Why isn’t this always switched on automatically when you set a faster shutter speed? Is that mainly to make photographers consciously choose the loss of flash power and other tradeoffs, or are there technical reasons as well?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
3
Is this a conscious decision that manufacturers have made not to include such feature, so that photographers can be aware of the HSS flash power limitations?
In my opinion, yes, I think this is why it's usually implemented the other way around: that you have to turn HSS on, and then the camera only stops using HSS if the shutter speed falls below sync speed. Otherwise, the shutter speed stops at sync speed with flash. The shooter needs to make the conscious decision to trade off a -2EV power drop for the faster shutter speeds with HSS.
Given that speedlights are the lowest-power strobes you can use, often using one effectively is about using your power as efficiently as possible. For some folks, say wedding shooters who need faster recycling, a safety rail keeping them out of the HSS "power-suck" zone may be a feature, not a bug.
Implementing it as you suggest, as an auto-switched mode based on shutter speed is likely to result in a lot of very confused shooters wondering what's wrong with their flash when they didn't change any flash settings but suddenly lost two stops of power. Without HSS set, having shutter speeds max out at the sync speed forces shooters to be aware of the sync speed "border" and to make the decision to cross it.
Originally by user27440. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user27440
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Usually it’s a deliberate design choice, because HSS has important tradeoffs. Once HSS is used, flash efficiency drops significantly, recycle times can increase, and you may lose around 2 EV or more of usable flash power. Many photographers would rather have the camera stop at normal sync speed than silently switch into a weaker flash mode.
That said, some systems do automate it. Nikon’s Auto FP sync can switch into HSS automatically when enabled in the camera menu, and some third-party systems can do the same with compatible triggers.
There are also technical reasons not to make it universal or seamless. Around the sync-speed transition, shutter travel timing matters: it’s not just the selected shutter speed, but how long the sensor is fully uncovered. That can make the handoff between normal sync and HSS imperfect, sometimes causing edge darkening near the transition range.
So the answer is: both. Some brands already offer automatic HSS behavior, but many systems require an explicit HSS setting because it changes flash performance enough that manufacturers prefer the photographer to opt in consciously.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can the Nikon D610 sync flash at 1/250s without Auto FP, or is it limited to 1/200s?
Do Canon DSLRs support high-speed sync, and what flash do you need?
Why won’t my Yongnuo YN560 IV do high-speed sync on a Nikon D750?
Is there any downside to leaving Nikon flash sync set to 1/320s Auto FP all the time?
Panasonic FZ1000: Does Auto shutter use the electronic shutter above 1/4000s with flash/FP sync?