Why does the Nikon D7000 pop-up flash preflash when controlling an off-camera TTL flash?

Asked 1/8/2011

4 views

2 answers

0

On a Nikon D7000, I’m using an off-camera SB-600 in TTL via the camera’s built-in Commander mode. Even when the pop-up flash is set not to contribute to the exposure, it still emits a preflash before the shot. Why is that necessary, and what is the camera actually measuring?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

12

So, actually, the preflash is a two-way dialog between the control flash (in this case, built in to the D7000) and the remote units. There's a reverse-engineered (and several years old, so possibly slightly out of date) explanation of the Nikon optical protocol by Alson van der Meulen. (The site is offline but archived.)

Basically, the control flash fires a minimal pulse, which actually triggers a reduced-power response from the remote flashes. The TTL system in the camera measures this response, and uses it to calculate the right power levels for each. (This may or may not include the control flash.)

Then, the controller flashes again with a reduced-power series of pulses which digitally encode instructions for the remotes, and in response every flash that's included in the exposure fires its main pulse.

All of this happens so quickly that it's impossible (or at least extremely difficult) to observe it unaided.

However, the last control flash actually happens with the shutter open, so even though it's at low power, if you have a wide aperture, or if a reflection of the camera appears in the scene, it can actually be seen. I assume this is a necessity in order to get the timing to work out.

(This works the same way for Pentax as well, although without separate control groups. I assume Canon and Olympus are basically the same but I don't know.)

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Because in Nikon CLS/optical TTL, the pop-up flash is acting as the commander, and it must communicate with the remote flash using light pulses before the exposure.

That preflash is not mainly for lighting the scene. It serves two jobs:

  1. Communication: the built-in flash sends coded pulses telling the remote flash what to do.
  2. TTL metering: the commander requests a low-power preflash from the remote unit, the camera measures that returned light, and then calculates the remote flash power needed for the actual exposure.

So even if the built-in flash is set not to appear in the final image, it still has to flash in order to command and meter the remote TTL flash. The final exposure can exclude the pop-up’s light, but the control pulses still happen before the shutter opens.

This is why optical wireless TTL requires the pop-up flash to be raised on the D7000. If you want to avoid visible commander flashes entirely, radio triggers or a different commander solution are the usual alternative.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer