Why does the Canon PowerShot G7 allow faster shutter speeds only at smaller apertures?
Asked 12/6/2013
1 views
2 answers
0
On my Canon PowerShot G7 in Manual mode, the maximum shutter speed changes with aperture. For example, it allows 1/2500s at f/8, but only up to 1/1600s at f/2.5. I expected the camera to allow the same maximum shutter speed regardless of aperture, or perhaps even faster speeds at wider apertures. Why does this happen? Is it normal behavior for this camera?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
7
Since the limitation appears to be with regard to specific positions of the aperture diaphragm it is most likely a mechanical limitation of the camera's design. The limitations you have described are clearly outlined on page 49 of the Canon PowerShot G7 Advanced Camera User Guide, so this is expected normal behavior for this camera. As the focal length increases the effective aperture will change for the same position of the diaphragm mechanism so it appears the specific shutter speed limitations apply to a specific position of the diaphragm.
This would lead one to assume, without any confirmation available from Canon that we could find on this point, that the camera has a leaf shutter. The wider the selected aperture is (lower the f-number) then the amount of time it takes the mechanical parts to move from being closed to open all the way becomes more critical to the amount of exposure on the edges of the frame and depth of field of the entire frame, thus the longer/slower the fastest possible shutter speed is for that selected aperture value.
Don't forget that aperture numbers are the denominator of a fraction. At f/2.8 the effective aperture is 1/2.8th the focal length of the lens. At f/8 the effective aperture is 1/8th the focal length of the lens. The aperture settings that limit the shortest shutter speed to 1/1600 second are the widest settings (f/2.8 at wide angle), those that limit the shutter speed to 1/2000 second are the mid-range apertures(f/3.2-3.5 at wide angle), and those that allow a fastest shutter speed of 1/2500 second are the smallest apertures (f/4 and up at wide angle). All shutter speeds below the shortest value for a given aperture are also available with that aperture.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes — this is normal for the G7. The camera’s manual documents these limits, so it’s expected behavior rather than a fault.
The likely reason is the G7 uses a leaf shutter (or a similar shutter design integrated with the lens/aperture mechanism), not a separate focal-plane shutter like a DSLR. With this type of shutter, wider apertures mean the shutter/diaphragm has to move farther to fully open and close, which limits the fastest possible shutter speed. At smaller apertures such as f/8, the opening is physically smaller, so the mechanism can complete the exposure faster and allow higher top shutter speeds.
So the maximum shutter speed is tied to the physical aperture opening, not just the exposure settings. That’s why you can get 1/2500s at f/8 but only 1/1600s at f/2.5.
In short: smaller aperture opening = less travel for the shutter mechanism = faster maximum shutter speed. This is common behavior with leaf-shutter compact cameras.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does the Nikon P7800 have a slower maximum shutter speed at wider apertures?
Why is the Fujifilm X30 limited to 1/1000s at wide apertures in aperture priority mode?
Why does my Nikon D7000 limit shutter speed to 1/250s with flash, and how can I use faster speeds?
How does high-speed sync let a flash work above the camera’s X-sync speed?
If ISO stays the same, how do aperture and shutter changes affect a photo with the same exposure?