Why does the Canon EOS Rebel XT sound louder than a newer DSLR, and can it be made quieter?
Asked 5/6/2013
5 views
2 answers
0
I upgraded from a Canon EOS Rebel XT to a Canon 50D, and the XT now seems much louder by comparison, with a sharper mirror/shutter sound. Is this normal for that model? Why would it be louder than newer Canon DSLRs, and is there any way to reduce the noise?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
3
I've had a few Canon DSLRs, one being the Canon Rebel XT. It does have a distinctive sound, one that I could pick out of a blind lineup against other Canon DSLRs.
The biggest reason that it is louder is that it was a very early model in the entry level digital SLR camera arena. The Canon Digital Rebel was the only other predecessor in the line. Therefore Canon simply didn't have much experience in this mostly plastic body production. Along the same lines, adding in the additional hardware necessary to keep it quiet was likely low on the list of important features in such an early low end model.
Since then, many models have come out with special silent shooting modes. These really take the sound dampening to a new level and are a great reason to upgrade if you need this feature. I have found the modes very useful when in a Church or similar situation.
How can you quiet it? Really you have very few options. The one I will suggest is to use mirror lockup if the Rebel XT has it(sorry I don't remember off hand). This will keep the mirror up but obstruct your view, not necessarily reducing the noise, but letting you control the noise at least.
See these other questions for more detail on this topic:
Originally by user4892. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4892
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—this is normal. The Rebel XT is an early entry-level DSLR, and its mirror/shutter mechanism has a distinctive, sharper sound than many later Canon bodies. Newer and higher-end DSLRs often include better internal damping to reduce mirror slap noise, and some models also add quiet/silent shooting modes.
Those quieter modes usually work by changing mirror movement timing, such as slowing it and delaying its return. That can reduce noise, but it’s a design feature of the camera body—you can’t realistically add it to an XT after the fact.
So the XT isn’t necessarily faulty; it’s mostly a difference in body design and damping compared with newer cameras like the 50D. In practice, there isn’t a simple way to make the Rebel XT significantly quieter beyond normal handling, and any major modification would be impractical.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does my Canon 7D sound louder than my Rebel XTi when shooting and autofocusing?
Is the Canon 1100D / Rebel T3 shutter and mirror noise unusually loud?
Why does the Canon 77D sound louder than the 200D/SL2 when taking a photo?
Canon EOS 550D vs 50D: which is the better buy for serious photography?
Why does a flash make a rising whistling sound while recycling?