Why does Lightroom mark published photos as 'Modified to Re-Publish' when I haven't changed anything?
Asked 9/12/2016
2 views
2 answers
0
In Lightroom CC 2015.6.1, photos I publish to services like Facebook, Flickr, SmugMug, and jf Collection Publisher sometimes move from "Published Photos" back to "Modified Photos to Re-Publish" even when I haven't edited them. For example, I published 169 images, then the next day 44 were marked as modified without me opening or changing anything. I know I can choose "Mark as Up-To-Date," but I want to understand the cause. What makes Lightroom do this, and is it image edits, metadata changes, or a Lightroom bug?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
9y ago
2 Answers
1
There are a number of possible causes of this.
One can be changes to metadata, not images (and you have some control over this in each publishing setup). These changes can in fact be indirect, for example changes to a keyword itself can cause republishing of every photo with that keyword attached. Some plugins (Smugmug's own for example) will be smart about the republish and send only the metadata, though you cannot see this in the published folder display itself.
There was also a bug/feature in 2015.6 (I think -- the one where they introduced the adjustable upright features). This resulted in a different set of develop data internally when it was used, giving a different digest and in turn marking it for publish. The bug/feature was that if you did NOT have a preview built for an image before the upgrade, building the preview would change the develop data, which in turn would mark the image to republish. You could quite literally sit on a published folder, and as it would build previews watch one by one images flip from published to to-publish. Supposedly this was addressed in the next version, though also adobe never really acknowledged what I saw (their comments were all Mac related but I saw this on Windows). I did a build of standard previews of all images, then marked all as published (as they were when I started), but this was VERY tedious as you have to do it by published collection.
The other possibility is that the publishing is not being successful, though you can probably see this. Some of the online publish plugins can get errors, leaving the image still marked for publish on the next run (as opposed to retrying in that publish run).
And of course changing image data, as you would expect, can cause it.
Originally by user28109. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user28109
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
This can happen for more than one reason, and it isn’t always a real image change.
A common cause is metadata updates rather than edits to the photo itself. In Publish Services, changing keywords or other metadata can mark files for re-publish. Even indirect changes—like editing a keyword used by many photos—can trigger this. Some publish plugins may only resend metadata, even though Lightroom still shows the image as needing re-publication.
There was also a Lightroom 2015.6-era bug related to internal develop data changes (notably around newer Upright-related adjustments). In some cases Lightroom recalculated the image’s internal “digest,” decided it had changed, and flagged it for publish even if you hadn’t intentionally edited it.
So the most likely explanations are:
- metadata changed,
- a plugin triggered a metadata-related update,
- or Lightroom 2015.6.1 is hitting a known publish-status bug.
Check each publish service’s metadata options and plugin behavior first. If the photos truly haven’t changed, the issue is likely Lightroom/plugin side rather than user error.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can Lightroom replace edited photos on Flickr instead of uploading duplicates?
Can Lightroom 4 manually mark a failed SmugMug publish as published?
Which photo-sharing services let Lightroom re-publish updated photos without losing comments or treating them as new uploads?
Can Lightroom replace a Flickr photo with an updated edit, and how long should it take?
How should I embed a Creative Commons license in JPEG metadata?