Why does focus change the framing when shooting through a jeweler’s loupe on an iPhone?
Asked 12/29/2018
4 views
2 answers
0
I’m photographing a small D&D miniature with an iPhone in VSCO and a 10x jeweler’s loupe taped over the camera to try focus stacking. When I change the focus point, the image framing shifts slightly, almost like it zooms out, so the stacked images don’t line up well. The loupe edges are also faintly visible in the frame.
Why does changing focus alter the field of view in this setup, and is there any practical way to avoid it?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
2
Focusing by moving a simple lens or an entire compound lens as a single unit will change the field of view. When the effect is seen in a camera lens, it's known as focus breathing. Some camera lenses, use "internal focusing", moving only certain groups within the compound lens, to avoid focus breathing. Since you're using a loupe and don't have control of the individual elements, the apparent change in focal length is likely unavoidable.
I have not attempted focus stacking. However, I would consider using a mirrorless system with any internal-focus lens and extension tubes with pass-through electrical contacts.
You can also check your focus stacking software for settings to align images despite being taken at slightly different focal lengths. For instance,
align_image_stackhas options to optimize for field of view, radial distortion, center shift, and XYZ position. Optimizing for field of view (-m) is the main option that appears to be applicable for focus stacking. Optimizing for Z position (-z) also seems as if it would be helpful. I would just try different options with reduced resolution images until I found something that seems to work.
Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user75526
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
What you’re seeing is essentially focus breathing: changing focus also changes the effective field of view. With a simple add-on optic like a jeweler’s loupe, focus changes can alter magnification, so the image appears to zoom slightly as focus shifts.
Because the loupe is a simple external lens and you can’t control its internal elements, this is likely inherent to the setup rather than caused by the visible loupe edges. The edge visibility may indicate imperfect alignment or coverage, but it’s not the main reason the framing changes.
In dedicated camera lenses, some designs reduce this effect using internal focusing, where only certain lens groups move. Your loupe-on-phone setup doesn’t offer that kind of correction.
Practical options:
- Let your focus-stacking software align the frames before blending.
- Minimize focus changes and keep the setup very rigid.
- For better results, use a camera/lens setup designed for close-up work, such as a mirrorless camera with an internal-focus lens and extension tubes with electrical pass-through contacts.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can a light-field camera or focus stacking make a miniature scene look life-size?
How can I reduce halo artifacts when focus stacking macro images in Helicon Focus?
Does a zoom lens distance scale mean the lens is parfocal?
Can I reduce low-light noise by stacking frames from an iPhone video into one photo?
Can a macro bellows reduce focus breathing for focus stacking?