Why does darktable look darker at “fit to screen” than at 100% zoom?
Asked 8/22/2020
2 views
2 answers
0
In darktable, a RAW image appears noticeably darker at “fit to screen” than it does at 100% zoom. As I zoom out from 100% toward fit view, the image gets progressively darker. Exporting the image to a 16-bit TIFF and opening it in GIMP makes it look closer to darktable’s 100% view. Is this expected behavior from darktable’s preview/rendering pipeline, a quality setting issue, or a bug?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
2
Two options come to mind.
1).
Darktable is showing you a representation of the RAW data, processed through it's own 'pipeline' - a series of computations that converts that data into something you can see on screen. One of the early stages is de-mosaicing where the sensors data is converted into RGB values for each pixel. This can be complex and slow so Darktable allows the user to set the quality of display for different sizes of display.
eg.
8.1.2. Lighttable
don't use embedded preview JPEG but half-size raw
Check this option to not use the embedded JPEG from the raw file but process the raw data. This is slower. (default off).
high quality thumb processing from size
If the thumbnails size is greater than this value, it will be processed using the full quality rendering path which is better but slower (default 720p).
8.2.1. Quality
demosaicing for zoomed out darkroom mode
Interpolation when not viewing 1:1 in darkroom mode: “always bilinear (fast)” is fastest, but not as sharp. “at most ppg (reasonable)” is using ppg + interpolation modes specified below, “full (possibly slow)” will use exactly the settings for full-size export (default “at most ppg (reasonable)”).
2). Darktable has lots of settings for colour management and applying icc profiles. The Colour Management System (CMS) uses the profile to make the display of the RGB values appear the same across different pieces of software and device. For Gimp and Darktable to display the image the same they must both be using the same icc profile and display intent. Both software's try to use the system display settings but it may be worthwhile checking what the setup is.
see 3.2.6. Color management in the Darktable manual.
and Chapter 11. Color Management with GIMP and 1.3. Color Management in the GIMP manual
Originally by user60903. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user60903
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
This is most likely a preview/rendering-path difference rather than exposure actually changing with zoom. In darktable, lower-zoom views and thumbnails may use a faster, lower-quality pipeline, while 100% view can use a higher-quality render from the RAW data. That can make brightness or tonality look different between “fit” and 100%.
A likely cause is darktable’s preview settings, such as whether it uses the embedded JPEG preview or a reduced-size RAW path, and at what size it switches to full-quality processing. Check the lighttable/darkroom performance and preview-quality options and force high-quality rendering for larger previews if available.
If the exported file consistently looks darker than what darktable shows on screen, that points to a display/export mismatch rather than zoom alone. Since you noted TIFF behaves differently from RAW, the issue may be tied to RAW processing or preview handling. In that case, updating darktable, resetting preview-related settings, and comparing with color management disabled/enabled are sensible troubleshooting steps. If it persists, it may indeed be a software bug.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do my Darktable JPEG exports lose star detail compared with the preview?
Why do Darktable and Lightroom render the same RAW file differently by default?
How can I run darktable-cli without hitting the locked database error?
Why do RAW photos look different in darktable than on my Sony camera, and can darktable apply the camera’s settings automatically?
Best Darktable and GIMP color-space workflow for printing photos