Why does 'Brother Backlit Sky' work as a metering guide in Understanding Exposure?
Asked 6/29/2011
3 views
2 answers
0
In Bryan Peterson’s Understanding Exposure, the 'Brother Backlit Sky' guideline is suggested for backlit sunrise or sunset landscapes: meter the sky to the side of the sun, then use that reading for the exposure. I understand that camera meters try to render whatever they see as a middle tone, but I’m still unclear on the logic behind this method. Why is metering the sky beside the sun a useful baseline, and what makes it produce a more natural-looking result than metering directly from brighter or darker parts of the scene?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
4
All the 'Brothers' in Understanding Exposure are an attempt to give you a simple, normally consistent thing that you can meter off that shouldn't be too far to the extreme. Metering off the sky, plant foliage, and other reflectively moderate items give you a solid baseline.
The idea is that here is an object that relative to the normal scene should be a bit..in the middle so to speak. He's not asking you to meter off something pure black or pure white because then it would throw the scene out of whack.
In reality, its a bit of a novelty to learn until you really 'understand exposure' in which case you should be picking your metering based on your own judgement of whats important to you in the scene.
Originally by user1917. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1917
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
The idea is to meter from something that is neither an extreme highlight nor an extreme shadow. Camera reflected-light meters tend to place what they measure near a middle tone, so if you meter from something very bright or very dark, the exposure can be pushed in the wrong direction.
'Brother Backlit Sky' works because the sky off to the side of the sun is often a reasonably moderate reference compared with the sun itself, deep shadows, or very dark foreground elements. It gives you a consistent baseline that is less likely to fool the meter than metering directly from the brightest or darkest parts of the scene.
In other words, the book’s 'Brothers' are simple metering shortcuts: use a part of the scene that’s closer to the middle, and you’ll usually get a pleasing starting exposure. As you gain experience, you move beyond the shortcut and choose what to meter based on what matters most in the image and which tones you want to preserve.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why meter a night scene wide open, then stop down and recalculate the shutter speed?
What does it mean when a camera meter is "confused by contrast"?
How does an incident light meter determine exposure compared with a reflective meter?
Why does my sunrise photo show noise at ISO 100, and how should I meter and set white balance?
How should I meter sunrise and sunset scenes for silhouettes or balanced exposure?