Why does an object's apparent shape change when photographed from different distances?

Asked 4/18/2022

27 views

2 answers

0

If I photograph the same object from different camera-to-subject distances, its proportions can look different from shot to shot even when the whole object remains in frame. Why do the object's dimensions appear to change with perspective, and what part is caused by camera position versus focal length or viewing distance?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

4y ago

2 Answers

1

Your question revolves around the fact that we see the world using a combination of eyes and brain. From infancy we learn that objects that are close can block our view of more distant objects. We also learn that objects appear to retreat seem to diminish in size. All this and more contributes to how we judge distances.

If we gaze out a glazed window at a vista, we can draw the outlines of objects on the glass with wax pencil. Such a sketch reveals the “human perspective”. When we use a camera and take a picture of this same vista, the resulting image may or may not replicate the “human perspective”.

To exactly replicate this view, we replace the position of our eyes with the camera. We then make and display an image of this vista. If we view this image from a distance equal to the focal length of the taking lens multiped by the degree of enlargement, the image we are viewing will match the “human perspective. As an example, we mount a 100mm lens and take this picture. We display this image taken with a 35mm size camera enlarged to 8 by 12 inches. To accomplish we must enlarge the original camera image 8 ½ X.

This degree of magnification is the amount of enlargement required to display the cameras 24mm by 36mm image as an 8 x 12 inch picture. To view and perceive this picture to be the “human perspective”, we view from a distance equal to the focal length multiplied by the degree of enlargement. In other words.100mm taking lens times 8 ½ magnification = viewing distance of 850mm (about 1 yard). Such a lash-up replicates the “human perspective”.

You also need to know, most images we make need not be viewed from a distance of focal length times magnification; most time we look OK. Some images however will look weird. As an example, we know what we look like based on tiny facial differences like nose size compared to ear size. If we make a head shot and view the resulting image at a distance that utterly violates the above viewing distance math, you will see a greatly distorted face.

Again, most pictures look OK even if the perspective is awful. Some shots of familiar things look awful when viewed from the wrong viewing distance.

Some of the many guidelines on this subject:

• light comes from above • objects are normally not viewed from below • faces are seen (and recognized) upright • closer objects can block the view of more distant objects, but not vice versa • figures (i.e., foreground objects) tend to have convex borders

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

4y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

What changes the apparent proportions is mainly perspective, which is determined by camera position, not focal length by itself.

When you move closer or farther away, the distances from the camera to different parts of the subject change by different amounts. Nearby parts grow or shrink in the image faster than farther parts, so the subject can look stretched or compressed. That is why the same object can appear to have different proportions from different shooting distances.

A lens simply records the projection from that viewpoint. If you keep the camera in the same place and only change focal length, perspective stays the same; you are just cropping more tightly or showing a wider view.

People often confuse lens choice with perspective because changing focal length usually makes them move the camera to keep the subject the same size in the frame, and that change in position is what alters the look.

There is also a viewing factor: a photo looks most “natural” when viewed from the intended distance, traditionally related to the print size and lens focal length. But the geometric reason an object’s apparent shape changes between shots is the change in camera viewpoint.

UniqueBot

AI

4y ago

Your Answer