Why does adding one adjustment layer make my TIFF file much larger?
Asked 2/28/2014
4 views
2 answers
0
I open a 40 MB TIFF in Photoshop, add a single Curves adjustment layer, and save without flattening. With my usual TIFF options, the file jumps to about 133 MB, even though I haven’t resized or made any other edits. If I delete the adjustment layer, the file goes back to around 40 MB. Why does one adjustment layer increase the TIFF size so much?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
5
The comments have really answered the question here: The behaviour you're seeing is as you should expect.
The settings for adjustment layers alone have no equivalence in any of the TIFF content standards. TIFF does allow for vendor specific extensions and this would be an example of one but saving to a nonstandard TIFF would be pointless if nobody could open it without an Adobe application. In order to remain compatible you have to add to your source image the resulting images of the adjustment layer changes alone, the source image with changes applied and the mask. Even using PSD if you enable the compatibility options it may do something similar to the file size (I didn't check).
Given that TIFF tries to be all things to all graphics formats right from group 3 fax through to high bit depth rendering and multiple layers there is always going to be a point where following the standard introduces a significant compromise.
In this case file size is that compromise and if it concerns you then you may need to store your content in a more appropriate format such as the native Photoshop format. PSD is unlikely to be going anywhere for quite some time.
Originally by user14028. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user14028
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
This is normal behavior. A standard TIFF doesn’t really have a universal, native way to store Photoshop adjustment layers in a fully editable form. To keep the file compatible, Photoshop may need to store extra image data along with the original image data, such as the adjustment result and related mask/layer information. That can greatly increase file size even when the visible edit is simple.
So the jump isn’t caused by the Curves change itself being “large” — it’s caused by the extra layered/editable data required to preserve that adjustment inside a TIFF. If you remove the layer or flatten the file, the TIFF can go back to something much closer to the original size.
In short: layered TIFFs can become much larger than flat TIFFs, especially when Photoshop is preserving compatibility and editable layer data.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why is a 16-bit TIFF much larger than the original RAW file?
Why does a stitched panorama TIFF become much larger than the original JPEGs?
Why does Lightroom create a TIFF when using “Edit in Photoshop” on a CR2 file?
Why do colors lose saturation when I merge layers or export a JPEG in Photoshop?
Why can two 2000×2000 JPEGs saved at the same quality have drastically different file sizes?