Why does a DSLR behave differently in optical viewfinder mode versus live view?
Asked 7/10/2011
4 views
2 answers
0
On a DSLR such as the Nikon D5100, some features and behavior change depending on whether you compose through the optical viewfinder or use live view on the rear screen. For example, autofocus can be slower in live view, some AF modes may be unavailable, battery use is higher, and certain overlays or scene-detection features only appear on the LCD. What is happening technically inside the camera in each mode, and why do some functions work differently or disappear? Also, what real technical advantages does live view enable compared with the optical viewfinder?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
12
To answer some of your questions directly, since you asked a few of them. First off, the mechanics of previewing a scene with the view finder vs. with live view are different. When viewing the scene through the view finder, you are seeing a direct optical projection of the scene as the lens attached to the camera sees it. Light is bent via a mirror from the lens, up through a focusing screen, and projected to your eye via a pentamirror or pentaprism. There are advantages and disadvantages of using the viewfinder, just as there are with using live view. To name two of the most important: focusing can be difficult without a dedicated focusing screen, and you generally can't see depth of field correctly through the view finder. As you mentioned yourself, its also dangerous to look directly at the sun without live view...this is because the intensity of the sun is being directed strait at your eye, and focused more tightly. Such intense light is very likely to blind you if you are not careful.
The reason you don't have phase-shift AF available when using live view is because of where the AF sensor is. Its actually located beneath the mirror that redirects the scene to the viewfinder. The mirror is actually what they call a half-silvered mirror, which only redirects part of the light of the scene to the viewfinder...the rest passes through the mirror, and reflects off of a perpendicular mirror below it. This second mirror redirects the remaining light to the metering and AF sensors, which are in the bottom of the sensor cabin. When you use live view, the mirrors fold up and out of the path of light coming through the sensor. Live view is exactly that...a direct representation of the light focused on the sensor without any obstructions in the way. Without the mirror, the AF sensor can't process the scene, so neither AF nor AF-C focus modes are available in live view.
Live view itself has its benefits. While it limits your auto-focus capabilities, most other functions of the camera are still available. Live view presents a much larger sample of the scene, and also allows the scene to be digitally zoomed in on. This facilitates manual focus or finer focus adjustments after AF. You usually have a composition grid that can facilitate you when you compose a scene. Live view also allows you to see the exact depth of field produced by your aperture setting, assuming you have an aperture preview button. When depth of field is an important compositional factor, live view is the only way to go. Contrast AF is also available in live view, and while it is usually slower than AF, it is still an automatic focus mode that can get you most of the way there. Finally, adjusting exposure with live view tends to be easier. Metering is based off the whole scene being imaged by the sensor, and adjustments to your exposure settings are usually immediately available. Aperture adjustments are usually visible in the view finder, however it is more difficult to see the effect of shutter speed or ISO changes without live view.
Originally by user124. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user124
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A DSLR works very differently in the two modes.
With the optical viewfinder, light from the lens is redirected by the mirror up to the focusing screen and prism/pentamirror, so you see the scene optically with no display lag. The camera also uses separate systems for metering and autofocus. This is fast and power-efficient.
In live view, the mirror is raised and the imaging sensor is read continuously to feed the LCD. That means the camera is working from the sensor output itself rather than the normal viewfinder path. This uses more power and can be slower, especially for autofocus on DSLRs that rely on the mirror-down phase-detect AF system in normal shooting.
That difference explains why some features change or disappear: some viewfinder-based AF behavior may not be available, battery drain increases, and some functions depend on whichever sensing/display path is active.
Live view also enables things the optical finder cannot do directly, such as on-screen grids and a closer preview of what the sensor will record. It can also be easier for tripod work or awkward camera positions.
Optical viewing remains better for stability, since holding the camera to your face is steadier than composing at arm’s length.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does the Sony A7 EVF/LCD image look jagged or pixelated in shooting mode?
Why does my Nikon D5600 overexpose through the viewfinder but meter normally in Live View?
Can you record what you see through a DSLR optical viewfinder while shooting?
Why use a DSLR’s optical viewfinder instead of live view, and when is live view helpful?
How do I stop a Canon EOS 1100D/Rebel T3 from turning off Live View after a few seconds?