Why do some Canon L lenses not need infrared focus compensation on B&W IR film?
Asked 6/13/2024
4 views
2 answers
0
The EOS-1V manual says that when shooting black-and-white infrared film, you should use a lens with an infrared index, but that with some Canon L-series lenses there is no need to compensate. Why is that physically possible?
I know infrared light usually focuses at a different point than visible light, which is why some lenses have an IR focus mark. But my EF 70-200mm f/2.8L IS II only shows IR marks at some focal lengths, not all of them. Why would certain L lenses, or certain zoom positions, not need any IR focus correction?
Originally by Alexey Malev. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Alexey Malev
2y ago
2 Answers
4
Lenses may have different focus markings for infrared light because, basically, different wavelengths of light are (usually) brought into focus by a photographic lens at different points. This is also the reason we can experience chromatic aberration in photos (see below). By adjusting the lens's focus according to the infrared focus marking, then the infrared component of the light will be brought into focus at the correct point on the focal plane. There's more information about that in this existing question:
Why is infrared light's focus point different from that of visible light?
![]()
Returning to chromatic aberration, one way lens manufacturers counter this is by using apochromatic lens designs, which basically use special types of glass, e.g. fluorite. These lenses are better corrected to focus all wavelengths of light at the same point - including infrared light. Canon L lenses use fluorite lens elements. More reading at the Canon Camera Museum:
Fluorite lenses: Corrective capabilities beyond the limits of ordinary optical glass
Basically, the answer to the question is that Canon L lenses don't need infrared focus markings because there's already been an attempt to design/manufacture them in such a way as to focus infrared light at the same point as visible light in any case. Some L lenses may have infrared focus markings, which should be used when applicable - because not all lenses can be corrected perfectly.
Originally by osullic. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
osullic
2y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Infrared focus correction is needed because lenses normally focus different wavelengths at slightly different distances. Infrared light often comes to focus at a different point than visible light, which is why some lenses include an IR index mark.
Some Canon L lenses can avoid needing extra IR compensation because they are better corrected for chromatic aberration, often through more advanced optical designs and special glass. In other words, they bring visible and near-infrared light close enough to the same focus that the shift is negligible for practical use.
That also explains why a zoom may show IR marks only at certain focal lengths: the amount of focus shift can vary across the zoom range. At some settings the shift is large enough to warrant a mark; at others it may be too small to matter.
So the manual’s statement is essentially saying that for those lenses Canon considers the infrared focus shift insignificant enough that you can focus normally when using B&W IR film.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI2y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How do I use the infrared focus index on a Canon EF 24-105mm f/4L lens?
Why does my Canon EOS-1V lock up with manual lenses on EF adapters?
How can I use the infrared scan channel to automatically detect dust and scratches on film scans?
Do I need an IR-cut filter to use a Canon EOS 60Da in daylight?
Why doesn't my Canon EOS 1000D record IR light after removing the IR-cut filter?