Why do scene modes change JPEG colors under warm indoor lighting?

Asked 3/13/2019

5 views

2 answers

0

I photographed the same indoor scene at night using a point-and-shoot camera that only saves JPEGs. The room was lit only by very warm LED filament bulbs (about 2200K), so to my eyes the scene looked strongly yellow. With the camera in Landscape mode, the JPEG looked much cooler, almost as if the room were lit by neutral or daylight-balanced light. In Sunset mode, the JPEG stayed much warmer and closer to what I thought I saw. Why would the camera intentionally change the colors so much between scene modes?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

7

Visible color of an object looks like something objective — if it looks yellow then it looks yellow, why change it in the first place? I just don't see how this color alteration is useful.

This is the fundamental misunderstanding. Visible color is not objective at all. That sounds surprising if you haven't really stopped to consider or investigate, but it really is the case. Remember the blue/yellow dress?

the dress

"Color" is actually a sensation that arises in the mind, not a physical property. Unlike, say, scent, which relies on specialized receptor neurons for each smell, color is largely the result of complex subconscious processing in the brain. Our color perception is very dependent on situation. (In more depth, see this answer to a different question).

So, that's the first thing. The camera can't just show you "true color", because it's just a dumb mechanical device. In some ways, the post-processing it does to create a JPEG mimics human color perception (because, hey, these cameras are made for humans), but fundamentally a lot of decisions are up in the air. This is why white balance is a user-selectable parameter even on the most primitive digital cameras, and on the ones where just about everything else is always automatic.

Related to this, then, is the matter of taste in processing for different subjects. For example, it's usually the case that when photographing people, we want to mute color a bit to downplay skin blemishes. And for landscapes, people often want pushed up colors to make greenery or fall foliage or rock formations or whatever stand out.

Your camera's scene modes are black boxes — you can't see what affect they actually have, beyond guessing from the name and the manufacturer's description. But they definitely do guide the camera's choice in color processing. It sounds like in your case, it also affects the camera's assumptions about white balance (which is fairly reasonable, as a landscape is not normally lit by candles).

If you're not happy with that, it's best to avoid scene modes. The ultimate version of this, of course, is shooting in RAW. You note that your camera can't do this, so it may just have to be a limitation you must accept for — but something to consider for now next time you get a camera.

See also Are scene modes, white balance, color tones, and similar just post-processing effects?

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

What you’re seeing is mainly white balance processing. In a JPEG-only camera, the camera must decide how to interpret the color of the light and then bake that decision into the file.

Scene modes change those assumptions. Landscape mode often assumes outdoor/daylight conditions and may cool the image to make foliage and skies look more “natural.” Sunset mode assumes the warm light is intentional and preserves more of that yellow/orange tone.

The key point is that color is not fully objective. Your brain constantly adapts to lighting, so what you perceive as “normal” or “white” in a warm room is not exactly what the sensor records. The camera only sees the light reaching the sensor; it has to guess the scene’s white point and render the JPEG accordingly.

So the camera isn’t necessarily “wrong” — it is applying different color rendering choices based on the selected scene mode. If you want control, use a manual white balance setting or shoot RAW on a camera that supports it, so you can adjust color later instead of accepting the camera’s baked-in JPEG interpretation.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer