Why do photos look sharper in Microsoft Paint than in Lightroom or other viewers?
Asked 2/17/2011
1 views
2 answers
0
When I view the same photo in different Windows programs, it often looks noticeably sharper in Microsoft Paint than in Picasa, Lightroom, or Nikon ViewNX2, especially when zoomed in or out to anything other than 100%. On Windows 7, Paint seems to make the image look more "snapped" or crisp at many zoom levels. Is Paint applying sharpening, or is this just a difference in how each program displays resized images?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
3
Whenever you see an image at anything other than 100% something called a filter must be applied to produce the pixels you see on the screen from the pixels in the image.
Different filters have different properties and performance. Some make images look sharper, some less, some work best for enlarging, some for shrinking. There are easily dozens of such filters (with variations) and the time it takes to apply them varies.
A number of applications such as Geeqie let you specify which filter to apply as a compromise between quality and performance. When you resize (AFAIK not for zooming) and image in Photoshop there are also several options which you can try out to see the differences. Modern machines can also use the graphics card (GPU) to perform sophisticated filters extremely fast. Only some software take advantage of this (if the machine can do it) but more and more do.
So to answer your question, MS Paint seems to be using a filter with sharpening properties on your system. Note that things like sharpening and noise-reduction are also types of filters, the only difference is that they output the same number of pixels as they get.
Originally by user1620. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1620
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
It’s most likely not extra sharpening. The difference usually comes from how each program resamples the image when displaying it at anything other than 100%.
If the image is zoomed in or out, the software has to calculate new screen pixels from the image pixels using a resize/interpolation filter. Different viewers use different filters and different quality/performance tradeoffs:
- some look smoother
- some look crisper or more contrasty
- some may look more pixelated
Paint may be using a simpler method that preserves hard pixel edges, which can make the image appear sharper or "snappier," especially at reduced sizes. Other programs may use smoother interpolation that looks less crisp but can be more natural.
At 100% view, sharpness should generally be much more comparable, since each image pixel maps more directly to screen pixels. JPEG decoding itself is not usually the main reason for the difference; the display scaling algorithm is the more likely explanation.
So yes: what you’re seeing is most likely a viewer/display-resizing difference, not Paint secretly improving the photo.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do my image colors look faded in Microsoft Paint?
Why does Lightroom show more color noise when zoomed out than at 1:1?
Why do photos look brighter in Lightroom than in other apps?
How do I assign separate color profiles to two monitors in Windows 7?
How can I sharpen tiny thumbnails in Photoshop while keeping JPEG file size low?