Why do my sRGB JPEGs still look oversaturated on some monitors?
Asked 10/12/2016
8 views
2 answers
0
I shoot RAW, edit in Lightroom on a Dell U2713H wide-gamut monitor, and export JPEGs tagged as sRGB. On my home computer, they look correct in color-managed apps and oversaturated in non-color-managed apps, which I understand.
What confuses me is that after uploading the same JPEGs to Google Photos, they still look oversaturated on my work computer using standard Dell monitors, even when viewed in a color-managed application.
I thought an sRGB-tagged JPEG should display normally on a typical monitor. What could cause oversaturation in this situation, and how can I check whether the problem is my editing display, my monitor profile, or the other screens people are using?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
9y ago
2 Answers
1
If you edited with a wide-gamut monitor, it is likely that in editing, you have chosen some colors that are 'out of gamut' for standard monitors. Your wide-gamut monitor can display them, but others can not. You can control for this by changing your monitor profile, using a monitor calibration tool. If you have Photoshop, there is a basic tool built in. You can switch easily in Photoshop by using the 'soft proof' setting. There is also a tool built into MacOS in the Displays setting. Here you can switch Display profile easily. (Sorry, don't remember if Windows has one).
Another issue may be the type of screen you are viewing on. Your main screen is likely a IPS-type display, where the image stays true to color even when viewed off-axis. But if the 'run of the mill' Dell displays are TN, then the color shifts dramatically when viewed off axis. There is really no fix for this, other than getting the colors within the gamut of the display, and within the sRGB color profile. (and viewing in the middle of the display).
Originally by user4880. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4880
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
If an sRGB JPEG still looks too saturated on another monitor, the most likely issue is not the file itself but display calibration/profile handling.
From the answers, likely causes are:
- your wide-gamut monitor/profile may not be set up correctly
- you may have edited colors that look fine on your display but exceed what a standard monitor can show
- the work monitor may be poorly adjusted or using a bad profile
- panel type/viewing angle differences can also affect appearance
What to do:
- verify your main monitor with calibration/profiling if possible
- use soft proofing to preview how the image should look on a standard/sRGB display
- compare known test images or a color checker on both screens
- check whether the work display/profile is actually correct, rather than assuming it is
In short: an sRGB export is the right choice for sharing, but it does not guarantee identical appearance on every monitor. If your home display is wide gamut, accurate profiling and soft proofing are important, and inexpensive office monitors may still show images too vividly or inaccurately.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I get accurate sRGB color from a wide-gamut monitor, and is an sRGB-only monitor better for non-color-managed apps?
Why do sRGB JPEGs look oversaturated in non-color-managed programs on a wide-gamut monitor?
Why do colors look oversaturated on a wide-gamut monitor in some photo viewers?
How can I make Lightroom under Wine use my monitor ICC profile?
Why do my photos look too red in some apps on a wide-gamut monitor?