Why do my RAW files look fine in-camera and Lightroom but dark and oversaturated in Photoshop CS6?
Asked 8/28/2013
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m shooting RAW on a Canon 6D and editing on a Mac. The photos look good on the camera preview and in Lightroom 4, but when I open the same files in Photoshop CS6 they appear darker, more saturated, and skin tones look too yellow. Even if I edit in Lightroom first and use “Edit In > Photoshop,” the image still looks wrong once it opens in Photoshop. I haven’t intentionally changed any camera or Photoshop settings. Could this be a color space, camera profile, or Photoshop color-management issue? How can I troubleshoot it?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
1
When viewing a RAW image in an image editing program, that program has to go through a number of transformation steps which affect the appearance of the image, in order to display the image.
Different RAW software packages will have differences in the way they apply these steps.
Since LR4 and CS6 are both by Adobe, I would suggest that it's because one of the two is too old to have a profile tailored to your camera.
This affects:
Colour space conversion
Red, green and blue in the Bayer filter are not necessarily the same hue as red, green and blue in the standard sRGB colour space. The camera does colour correction to convert the colours into the desired colour space, which is usually sRGB. If you an equivalent image in a RAW image editor, it will also do colour space conversion, but it may use a different colour matrix for the conversion due to the manufacturer of the RAW editing software not having access to the same colour matrices used in the camera (or the camera having been released later than the RAW editor). If your RAW editing software is correctly configured, this step should not cause any noticeable difference in the resulting picture. Those who know what to look for (for example, Canon or Adobe's signature colour profiles, which try to enhance skin tones and blues) may be able to notice the difference especially when testing.
Contrast / Gamma correction
Gamma correction is applied which converts from the linear values to gamma corrected values as required by digital image files. This correction is not a straight gamma correction; a contrast curve is applied to ensure that highlights and blacks curve off nicely. Some cameras store the camera's contrast setting in the RAW file and some RAW editors can use this; otherwise RAW editors will use an in-built contrast curve. This can create quite a noticeable difference between the in-camera JPEG and an equivalent RAW viewed in an image editor, or between multiple different RAW editors. The contrast curve affects not only the appearance of contrast but also, indirectly, the colour saturation. The great thing about working with a RAW file is that you have full control over the contrast curve applied in software, before lossy operations such as sharpening, noise removal or JPEG compression have to take place.
Originally by user3422. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user3422
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
This is most likely a Photoshop color-management/profile issue rather than a camera exposure problem.
A few key points:
- RAW files do not have a final baked-in look; each program interprets them through its own processing pipeline.
- Camera color space settings like sRGB vs Adobe RGB generally matter much more for JPEGs than for RAW capture.
- Since Lightroom and Photoshop should normally match closely, the fact that Lightroom looks correct but Photoshop does not suggests Photoshop may have a bad ICC/display profile or incorrect Color Settings.
What to check:
- In Photoshop, reset Edit > Color Settings to defaults.
- Check Photoshop preferences and any assigned/working ICC profile settings.
- Test by saving the file from Photoshop, then reopening it in Lightroom. If it looks fine in Lightroom, the problem is likely Photoshop’s display/profile handling rather than the actual file.
- Also consider software support/profile issues: if one app version is older, it may not have the best camera-specific rendering/profile for your 6D.
In short: don’t rely on the camera’s preview as a RAW reference, ignore the sRGB/Adobe RGB advice for this issue, and focus on Photoshop’s color settings/display profile first.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I make Lightroom 4 open Photoshop CS6 instead of Photoshop CS5.1?
Can Photoshop actions be used on RAW files in CS6?
Why does a calibrated monitor look oversaturated, while my prints come back dull?
Why do colors look oversaturated in Chrome on a wide-gamut monitor?
Why do colors look different across apps after monitor calibration?