Why do my Canon Rebel XS photos look cooler than a Canon 70D with the same settings?

Asked 5/29/2014

3 views

2 answers

0

I compared photos from my Canon Rebel XS and a friend's Canon 70D. We shot the same scene within seconds of each other using the same 50mm f/1.8 lens, ISO 100, 1/200 sec, f/1.8, and the same white balance setting (7000K / Shade). Even with those settings matched, my Rebel XS image looks noticeably cooler while the 70D image looks warmer. Why can two Canon cameras produce different color with the same lens and exposure settings?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

2

I wouldn't call the difference between these two photos "dull" vs. "vibrant". The difference is "cool" vs. "warm", in terms of color balance or "color temperature". The first image is cool, the second image is warm. Which of these you prefer really, ultimately, boils down to a matter of personal preference. This is why many specific cameras, such as the Canon 1D line, have many raving "color fans". Certain individuals really, really, really like the native unmodified color that comes out of certain cameras.

There are many reasons why these two cameras may perform differently. For one, your comparing a Rebel XS with a 70D. These two cameras are generations apart, not only that they are a good decade apart. There could be a multitude of hardware and firmware differences that lead to the differences in color balance that your seeing in these two images. Differences in the tone curves for built-in picture styles to differences in the natural response curve of the silicon used in the sensor can account for these differences.

I think the most obvious conclusion is that the two cameras had different picture styles selected. I don't see "Picture Style" in the list of EXIF data. It's probably a Canon custom EXIF property, so it may not be exported by default. If the two cameras had different picture styles chosen, then the in-camera JPEG output of both cameras will differ, even if you configure them otherwise as identically as possible. Canon cameras usually have around five built-in picture styles, from standard and neutral to faithful, landscape, and portrait. I'd be willing to bet that one camera is on a standard style, and the other is on faithful or portrait (both of which tend to warm and saturate a bit more). If either was on landscape, I'd expect the greens to be much more vibrant.

Originally by user124. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user124

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The difference is mainly a color-rendering/white-balance difference: your Rebel XS image looks cooler, while the 70D looks warmer.

That can happen even when exposure settings and the selected WB value are the same. Different camera models can interpret white balance, color, and JPEG processing differently because of sensor design, metering, image processor generation, firmware, and Canon’s color tuning. The Rebel XS and 70D are from very different generations, so it’s normal for their out-of-camera JPEGs to differ.

Also, a Kelvin number or preset like Shade is not a guarantee of identical color between bodies. Each camera may map that setting slightly differently.

So this doesn’t necessarily mean your camera is faulty—just that the two cameras have different native color responses. If you want them to match more closely, shoot RAW and adjust white balance/color in post, or create a custom white balance/picture style for each camera.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer