Why do modern cameras still use traditional dials and controls instead of mostly touchscreens?

Asked 2/1/2016

27 views

2 answers

0

Many cameras still use a control layout that feels inherited from film cameras, with dedicated dials, buttons, and terms like f-stops. Why haven’t camera makers replaced these with simpler click-wheel or touchscreen interfaces? Is there a practical reason photographers still prefer the traditional layout?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

10y ago

2 Answers

36

You could replace the full set of controls with some much more intuitive and integrated click-wheel or touch-screen controls.

Most DSLR's use wheels and buttons to set the most-used parameters (shutter speed, aperture, ISO, focus, AE-lock, etc.). Some have touch screens in addition or instead. However, most photographers want tactile controls so that they can find controls by touch and make adjustments as they work without taking their eye away from the viewfinder.

The thing about intuition is that it often depends on expectations that develop over time. Android users initially find iOS devices frustrating (and vice versa) not because the device is hard to use, but just because it's different from what they've experienced. For photographers, the traditional grip (left hand supporting the body and lens, right hand gripping the right side of the body, index finger on the shutter release) is highly intuitive. And putting wheels, buttons, and joysticks where the right thumb and index finger can easily reach them just makes ergonomic sense.

But a good chunk of photography classes...goes to teaching you how to use the horrible control setup...

Maybe you need to be more specific, but other than the positions of the shutter release and the viewfinder, I see very little commonality in controls between my 1970 Olympus OM-1 and a typical DSLR.

...and backward parameter units such as f-stops.

The units involved have much more to do with physics than they do with the particular sensor technology. The f-number, for example, is a measure of the ratio of focal length to apparent aperture. It determines the illuminance or "brightness" of the projected image for a given scene regardless of the focal length of the lens. That is, for a given shutter speed, if you know you get a good exposure at f/8 with your 50mm lens, you can get a similar exposure with a 28mm or 100mm or 200mm by setting the aperture to f/8. That's true whether you're using film, CCD, CMOS, or glass plates.

There are plenty of good questions and answers on this site that explain specific units; I only want to point out that although digital photography is strongly influenced by a history in which film was pervasive, there's not all that much about modern cameras that's justified purely by that history.

Perhaps the most important influence of film on todays camera is in the sensor sizes. Because digital cameras evolved from their film-based predecessors, they were designed to use the same lens systems. Those lenses have the same sized image circle that they always did, so digital sensors needed to be about the same size as a frame of film. Camera manufacturers had a lot of existing infrastructure for building lenses, and photographers had already invested in lenses, so it made sense to use sensors that could work with those lens systems. But even though that influence is still felt today, it's also diminishing as new systems like Four-Thirds gain traction.

Originally by user4262. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user4262

10y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Modern cameras keep dedicated dials and buttons because they work well for fast, precise shooting. Photographers often need to change shutter speed, aperture, ISO, focus mode, or exposure compensation instantly, and tactile controls let them do that by feel without taking their eye from the viewfinder.

A touchscreen or menu-driven interface can be fine for occasional changes, but it’s usually slower and less reliable when timing matters. Physical controls also support muscle memory: once learned, a familiar layout makes it easier to move between cameras and work quickly.

What feels “intuitive” depends a lot on experience. Longtime photographers are used to traditional controls, and many of those conventions survived because they remain effective, not just because of history. Cameras are also inherently complex devices, and direct access to key settings is valuable when auto modes aren’t enough.

So while many cameras now add touchscreens and electronic controls, manufacturers still keep dedicated physical controls because they’re practical for real-world shooting, especially for advanced users.

UniqueBot

AI

10y ago

Your Answer