Why do I see halos around edges when using A-HDR on my Pentax K-S2?
Asked 8/7/2022
4 views
2 answers
0
When I use the Pentax K-S2's A-HDR (advanced HDR) mode, bright halos appear around the edges of objects in the photo. Is this a normal side effect of in-camera HDR, or does it indicate a problem with the camera or settings?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
3y ago
2 Answers
9
Is it normal? Yes… and no.
It depends on the ability/quality of the HDR routine and its ability to recognise & correctly handle edges where the overall light level changes rapidly.
A low-ability algorithm will leave this halo to a greater or lesser extent - it's pretty much the trademark of poor HDR. This is an area where modern phones are beating regular cameras hands-down. They can form very well-defined masks to separate these contrast edges & the results are getting close to invisible.
For a DSLR etc, the best way to do this is actually in post, in Photoshop or a dedicated HDR app such as Aurora HDR [which I just learned is discontinued - the functionality has now been folded into Luminar Neo]
Some examples [chosen not by its inspiring subject matter but just because I rarely take photos that include sky;)… The processing was done on a small jpg not the original file, to make the results worse.
Photoshop, with the borders set intentionally high and overall settings to emphasise the bad edges. Clear halo. [Photoshop can do a lot better than this, but is not as good as dedicated software]

Aurora, at default settings, very slight halo

Aurora with intentionally aggressive settings, reasonably acceptable halo for the settings

AI-based algorithms will tend to improve on these results as they are developed further. My versions of Photoshop & Aurora are pre-AI. Newer software is likely to be better still.
Originally by user57929. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user57929
3y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—halos can be a normal side effect of in-camera HDR processing, especially if the camera’s algorithm is aggressive around high-contrast edges. It doesn’t necessarily mean your K-S2 is faulty.
What you’re seeing is commonly caused by HDR tone-mapping and/or strong edge enhancement (similar to unsharp masking). Less sophisticated HDR routines often leave visible light or dark outlines around objects, which is a classic HDR artifact.
If you want cleaner results, the usual advice is to avoid heavy in-camera HDR and instead:
- expose carefully for the scene,
- shoot RAW,
- adjust exposure and white balance in post,
- or merge bracketed exposures in dedicated editing software.
That generally gives you better control and fewer halos than automatic camera HDR modes.
So: normal for some HDR implementations, but not unavoidable if you use a different workflow.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI3y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do bright/dark halos appear around trees against the sky after raising shadows in RAW processing?
What causes red/blue fringes along object edges on a white background?
What causes bright halos around subjects, and how can I reduce them?
How do I enable autofocus on a Pentax K-S2 with an SMC Pentax-FA 80-320mm lens?
Is uneven flare on a Samyang 8mm f/3.5 fisheye a sign of a defective lens?
