Why do I see a textured 'leather-grain' pattern in smooth skies when using Lightroom sharpening mask view?
Asked 5/4/2019
3 views
2 answers
0
When I hold Alt/Option in Lightroom to view the sharpening mask, smooth sky areas show a strange textured or mottled pattern, almost like leather grain. In the normal image view and in exports, the photo looks fine, but I’m worried something may be wrong with my camera or files. I shoot RAW on an Olympus E-PL8, usually at the lowest ISO (200), and I can see this on multiple photos with sky. Is this banding, sensor noise, or just an artifact of Lightroom’s masking/sharpening preview?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
3
Even when the sky appears uniform to our eyes, it isn't. The index of refraction of air is affected by a number of things (e.g. the shimmering mirages you see over a hot road) - temperature, humidity, turbulence, pollution, density due to elevation, and probably others - especially at boundaries where one or more of these change rapidly. In addition, just because you don't see a white puffy cloud doesn't mean there aren't areas where there is a higher concentration of water vapor or ice crystals that just aren't dense enough for our eyes to detect them. These, along with sensor noise of various types, dirt/oil on lenses, and even the differences in algorithms used to process the sensor data, can all lead to what looks to be a uniform sky being actually very non-uniform, although the differences are all in the low-order bits of the image (i.e. they're small). Algorithms such as unsharp masking have a tendency to exaggerate these small differences, as you've noticed. You can use various forms of blurring to make those small differences disappear again, but probably at the expense of some additional image clarity elsewhere.
In other words, this really isn't something you should be concerned about. As long as your final images look good (i.e. you haven't boosted that non-uniformity too much), you should just ignore this, because it's normal.
Originally by user68706. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user68706
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
This is most likely normal fine image noise and slight real-world tonal variation in the sky, made much more obvious by Lightroom’s sharpening/mask preview and by strong inspection of smooth areas.
A sky that looks uniform to your eyes usually isn’t perfectly uniform in the file: atmospheric variation, haze/water vapor, turbulence, processing differences, and small amounts of sensor noise can all create subtle texture. When you use the Alt/Option sharpening mask view or push contrast/levels while inspecting, that low-level variation gets exaggerated and can look like a leathery pattern.
Based on the answers, this does not sound like a camera fault, and it’s not necessarily banding. Similar patterns can appear even at low ISO, especially when noise filtering is low/off or when you examine the image at high magnification.
If the normal image and exported file look fine, there’s probably nothing wrong. Judge the photo in normal view at sensible zoom levels, and use less aggressive sharpening/noise-reduction settings if needed.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What does Lightroom's Sharpening Masking preview show, and can I recreate that look?
Why do my photo prints show banding and texture in the sky on laser and inkjet printers?
Why do maze-like artifacts appear in lens flare areas of my RAW photos?
What causes the maze-like pattern in Lightroom’s 1:1 detail preview, and how can I reduce it?
Why do wavy lines appear when photographing a canvas painting, and how can I avoid them?