Why do I get hard banding in blue skies after merging HDR JPEG exposures?

Asked 5/26/2018

3 views

2 answers

0

I shot a 3-image bracket on a Canon EOS 5Ds R and merged the JPEG files in easyHDR Pro. In smooth blue skies I’m seeing obvious hard tonal transitions/banding. The original source images appear to show the same issue, so it may not be caused by the HDR software.

What typically causes this kind of artifact, and how can I avoid or reduce it when shooting and processing HDR images?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

7

Those artifacts look like the result of JPEG compression. Such compression artifacts are particularly likely to be visible in large flat areas with slowly changing intensity, like your blue sky.

If they are really sensor artifacts, then they would be in the raw files. Take a look. Make sure you are examining true raw files, not compressed raw files.

If this is due to compression, as it appears to be, compress less. At least don't compress until you make the final image, then chose the level of compression so that these artifacts are not visible. Any lossless compression is OK. Note that JPG has both lossless and lossy compression. The "quality" setting adjusts the tradeoff of how aggressive the lossy compression is versus the artifacts it causes. Only you can be the judge of what the right level is.

If you need really good quality, like to send out to have a large poster made, consider using only lossless compression. The forward differencing with LZW compression of TIFF files does a good job on flat areas like your sky, without introducing any artifacts at all.

Originally by user7603. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user7603

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This kind of hard transition in a smooth sky is most likely JPEG compression banding, not an HDR-specific problem. Large, low-detail gradients like blue skies make JPEG artifacts especially visible, and HDR processing can make them stand out even more.

To confirm the cause, check the original RAW files. If the banding is not in the RAWs, it was introduced by JPEG compression. If you’re only working from JPEGs, you’ve already baked in some loss before the HDR merge.

To avoid it:

  • Start with RAW files rather than JPEGs.
  • Do your HDR merge and editing before saving to JPEG.
  • Use lossless formats during editing/export where possible.
  • If you must save JPEG, use a higher quality setting and only compress at the final output stage.

If the artifact truly appears in the RAW files, then it would point to something other than JPEG compression, but based on the description, compression is the most likely cause.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer