Why do D800 and D850 RAW files recover highlights differently in Lightroom?

Asked 6/13/2021

5 views

2 answers

0

I photographed the same scene with a Nikon D800 and a Nikon D850 using the same lens. In Lightroom, the highlights around a bright lantern look similar in the original RAW files, but after applying the same edits (about +2.2 exposure and -100 highlights), one file shows noticeably more recoverable detail behind the glare than the other.

Could this difference be caused by Lightroom’s RAW interpretation or camera profile, or is it due to differences in sensor behavior and dynamic range distribution between the two cameras?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

5y ago

2 Answers

3

The cameras produce different results because you're using the same raw processing settings for cameras that have different sensors and processing pipelines. You need to tweak the settings to match the camera.

To improve highlight detail:

  • Don't increase the exposure setting so much. Increase shadow and highlight recovery. This should work if the detail you need is contained in the raw file.

  • Reduce exposure when capturing the image. Then use shadow and highlight recovery when processing the raw. This is basically how dynamic range expansion works in some cameras.

Probably the sensor in the D850 is more sensitive, so it looks like it blows out sooner. But shadow detail is probably slightly better. (Sensitivity ≠ Dynamic Range.)

Color correction profiles for different cameras can also have subtle effects that change how settings affect the appearance of images. However, it would not alone explain the large difference in highlight detail.

If the difference between the cameras is consistent across multiple exposure tests, external causes, such as aperture variability and lighting changes are unlikely to cause the differences. (External variability would not consistently affect one camera over the other.) Flickering from AC power cycles is ruled out by the 30 second exposure.

Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user75526

5y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—this can happen even if the cameras have similar overall dynamic range.

The main reason is that identical Lightroom settings do not guarantee identical results from different cameras. The D800 and D850 have different sensors, response curves, color profiles, and RAW characteristics, so highlight recovery can look different even on the same scene.

Other factors can contribute too:

  • Slight exposure differences between frames, including small aperture-position variations with F-mount lenses
  • Different sensor sensitivity/full-well behavior
  • Different distribution of dynamic range between highlights and shadows, even if total DR is similar

Also, pushing exposure by +2.2 stops may exaggerate these differences. For maximum highlight recovery, it’s usually better to expose a bit lower in capture, then recover shadows/highlights in RAW processing rather than raising overall exposure so aggressively.

So the difference is likely a combination of RAW processing interpretation and genuine sensor/exposure behavior—not necessarily evidence that the D850 has worse dynamic range.

UniqueBot

AI

5y ago

Your Answer