Why did my Kodak Portra 400 negatives come back looking black and white?

Asked 9/10/2011

2 views

2 answers

0

I shot Kodak Portra 400 color negative 120 film in a Hasselblad 503CW, but when the developed negatives came back from the lab they appeared black and white instead of color. How can color negative film end up looking monochrome after processing?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

9

They may have been "souped" in the wrong chemistry. For all the differences between colour and black-and-white films, they are, at heart, the same thing. The colour films simply have extra bits of chemistry, both in the film itself and in the developing chemistry, that adds colour to what is really just a black-and-white image.

In black-and-white photography, you simply cause metallic silver to precipitate out of silver halides that have been made reactive by exposure to light, then get rid of the remaining silver halides in the fixing process. In colour films, there are dye precursors that attach to the silver, and in the "blixing" process, the remaining halides and unattached dye precursors are removed ("fixing" the image) and the metallic silver is removed as well ("bleaching" the image), leaving only the dye clouds.

If the silver is not removed (that is, if there's something wrong with the bleach/fix bath, either due to depletion or an incorrect mixture) you will get a sort of colourized black-and-white image; if the developer chemistry does not convert the dye precursors to dye clouds (that is, if the chemistry used is a black-and-white developer rather than the usual C-41 chemistry), then you'll get essentially the same result as with with a black-and-white film (but with a colour cast to the negative).

If it were the film at fault (let's say, for argument's sake, that the part of the dye that lives in the emulsion went missing during manufacture), then the blixing process would have removed the silver, leaving no dye clouds behind, and your negs would have been either blank or just the faintest ghostly traces of density.

Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2719

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The most likely cause is that the film was processed in the wrong chemistry.

Color negative film like Portra 400 still records an underlying silver-based black-and-white image, but it also relies on color-forming chemistry during C-41 processing. In proper color processing, dyes are formed in the emulsion and the silver image is later removed, leaving the color dye image.

If the film is developed as black-and-white instead, the silver image can remain while the color-forming part of the process never happens, so the result looks like black-and-white negatives rather than normal color negs.

In short: your Portra probably wasn’t inherently defective; it was most likely “souped” in black-and-white chemistry or otherwise processed incorrectly by the lab. Contact the lab and ask what process they used for that roll.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer