Why can two similar cameras have different ISO ranges?
Asked 1/22/2014
3 views
2 answers
0
I’m comparing two Canon DSLRs that are often described as very similar, such as the 600D and 100D. Their quoted ISO sensitivity ranges are different, even though people often say they use the “same” sensor. What determines the ISO range a camera offers, and how much of that is due to the sensor versus the camera’s processing and firmware? I’m especially interested in whether the higher ISO range really matters for low-light shooting.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
11
If you're are talking about the range of ISO sensitivities available then it's simply a choice by camera manufacturers about how much gain (amplification) is applied to the sensor data. The highest settings are usually implemented in software by just doubling all the numbers after analogue to digital conversion, so it's entirely arbitrary how high they can be made to go.
The Canon 600D goes from ISO 100 to ISO 6400, whereas the newer 100D goes from ISO 100 to ISO 12800.
Lots of people claim that Canon have been using the "same 18MP sensor" in all APS-C models since the 7D. This conjures up images of a warehouse full of 18MP chips manufactured in 2007 that Canon keeps dipping into with each new release. In fact each sensor is different, but the differences are incremental based on the same basic design, hence the difference in ISO range (and other factors) between the 100D and 600D.
It's tempting to say that as sensors get better at handing noise, manufactures have increased the allowable range accordingly. But ISO ranges have expanded far faster than camera performance. The 20D only went up to ISO 1600, it's 2013 descendant the 70D goes a whopping three stops (x8) higher.
In essence it's become an arms race between manufacturers as the higher setting tend to suggest a camera is better in low light. Both the 100D and 600D offer an "expanded" ISO setting of 12800 for the 600D and 25600 for the 100D. It's hidden behind a setting so manufactures can claim a wide range, whilst at the same time preventing anyone from using it due to the very poor quality of detail captured with this setting.
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A camera’s quoted ISO range is not determined by the sensor alone. ISO is mainly about how much gain is applied to the sensor signal, plus how the camera processes the result.
Even if two cameras are very similar, differences in electronics, processor, firmware, and JPEG noise reduction can let the newer model offer a higher advertised ISO setting. At the top end, some ISO settings are effectively extended/software-boosted values, so manufacturers have some freedom in where they stop the published range.
That means a higher maximum ISO does not automatically mean dramatically better low-light image quality. It may just mean the camera is willing to amplify the signal more, often with more visible noise. For JPEG shooters, better in-camera processing can make higher ISO settings look more usable. For RAW shooters, those JPEG-engine differences matter less.
At the low end, ISO is more constrained by the sensor’s actual light-gathering and base sensitivity. So: sensor design matters, but the available ISO range is also strongly influenced by the camera’s processing pipeline and manufacturer choices.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What’s the difference between native ISO and unity gain ISO?
How does ISO 12232 sensitivity compare to ASA/ISO ratings?
What limits how large digital camera sensors can be?
How Sony ARW delta compression relates to dynamic range
What does ISO mean, and why do higher ISO settings add noise?