Why can larger camera sensors offer greater dynamic range?

Asked 5/14/2013

1 views

2 answers

0

I understand why larger sensors can affect depth of field and often have lower noise, but I’m still unclear on dynamic range. Why do larger sensors often have better dynamic range, and is it the sensor size itself or something else such as pixel size, pixel count, or sensor design?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

21

The size of the sensor does not matter, it is the size of the pixel. Having that said, bigger sensors like in full frame cameras tend to have bigger pixels.

You can estimate the size of the pixel by taking the size of the sensor and divide it by the number of pixels. This calculation is not accurate because most sensors have gaps between the pixels and these gaps differ in size. That is why I'm saying "estimate".

Now, think of a pixel in the sensor as a box and photons as balls. The bigger the box, the more balls it can contain.

Assuming we have box A and B. Box A can contain 256 balls and box B can contain 512 balls. Now lets arrange a box matrix of A type and throw a lot of balls in the air. We want gather some statistics of where the balls fell.

In the middle one of the boxes contains 256 balls and in the edges the boxes contains ~20 balls. We cannot know if in the middle only 256 balls fell or more. Our measure is limited to maximum for 256 balls.

Now lets repeat this experiment but now with boxes of type B. Now we can see that in the middle the box contains 347 balls and on the edges the boxes contains ~20 balls.

Our measure is far more accurate. That's exactly what happens with the photons hitting the sensor. Bigger surface can contain more photons and can measure a larger dynamic range. In our example the dynamic range is twice as big in the bigger box.

If the pixel is full of photons the translation to color will be a fully saturated color but with a larger pixel surface we will get a better result, thus, improved dynamic range.

Here is a picture that can demonstrate my explanation:

Dynamic Range Explanation

For deeper explanation you may want to check this article:

Dynamic_Range

Originally by user19909. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user19909

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A larger sensor does not automatically give more dynamic range by itself. What matters most is how much light each photosite can collect and how much noise the sensor adds.

Dynamic range is the span between the brightest signal a pixel can record before saturating and the darkest signal that still rises above noise. If pixels are larger, they can hold more charge and collect more photons, which improves the signal relative to noise and can increase dynamic range.

With a larger sensor, manufacturers often either use larger pixels or fit more pixels over a larger area. Larger pixels can improve per-pixel dynamic range; more pixels can also help when images are viewed at the same output size because noise can be averaged down.

But sensor size alone is not the whole story. Read noise and overall sensor quality matter a lot. A smaller sensor with lower pixel density and better electronics could outperform a larger, lower-quality sensor. In practice, full-frame cameras often have better dynamic range partly because they tend to be higher-end designs, not just because they are bigger.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer