Why can electronic first curtain shutter change bokeh at fast shutter speeds?
Asked 4/26/2020
1 views
2 answers
0
Many cameras offer electronic first curtain shutter (EFCS), using an electronic start to the exposure and a mechanical second curtain. This avoids some drawbacks of a fully electronic shutter, but people often report that EFCS can change the look of out-of-focus highlights or background blur, especially with wide apertures and fast shutter speeds. Why does this happen, and under what conditions is it most noticeable?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
8
The reason for the phenomenon is that at wide apertures in good light necessitating a fast shutter speed, most of the exposure is coming from a very narrow traveling slit between the first and second curtain.
The curtains before and after the slit are not at the same height, however.
The electronic curtain travels where the photosites are.
The mechanical curtain travels at significant distance from the sensor. In particular, there is an anti-aliasing filter and perhaps some protective glass on top of the sensor, and only then the shutter curtain.
Because the curtains are at different heights from the sensor, parallax effect becomes significant. The faster the shutter speed, the smaller the traveling slit is, and the problem becomes more pronounced.
To fix the issue, the shutter speed needs to be slowed down. Firstly, if the camera is not already at its lowest ISO setting, the ISO should be lowered to the lowest ISO. Secondly, if the shutter speed is still too fast causing the effect to appear, an ND filter could be used.
However, the best fix is to use shutter curtains that are at the same height from the photosites. So, if the second curtain is mechanical, the first should be mechanical too. Unfortunately, with all cameras, this is not possible.
Here is a diagram showing how the parallax between curtains affects the light coming into the camera. The black bars represent the shutter/curtains (electronic or mechanical) and the blue bar represents the image sensor.

- On the left, both the first and second curtain are at the same depth; no matter what angle the light enters at, the slit between them appears to be the same width.
- However, on the right where the curtains have different depths, light entering at a downwards angle is nearly blocked while light entering at an upwards angle effectively sees a wider slit.
The different angles of light are associated with different parts of the bokeh, so one side of the bokeh will get dimmer and dimmer until it is eventually cut off entirely. Also, the narrower the slit is, the smaller the angle at which light is blocked; this is what makes the effect more pronounced at shorter exposures.
Originally by user81735. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user81735
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
EFCS can alter bokeh because the exposure starts electronically at the sensor plane, but ends with a mechanical second curtain that travels some distance in front of the sensor. At fast shutter speeds, exposure is made through a very narrow moving slit. Since the electronic "first curtain" and the mechanical second curtain are not in the same physical plane, a small parallax effect occurs.
That mismatch matters most with wide apertures and bright light, where you need very fast shutter speeds. The narrower the traveling slit, the more visible the effect can become in out-of-focus highlights and background blur. Fully mechanical shutter operation does not have this same mismatch because both curtains travel in the same plane; fully electronic shutter also doesn’t create this specific EFCS artifact.
In practice, if you notice odd bokeh rendering with EFCS, reduce shutter speed or switch to full mechanical shutter. The issue is generally most pronounced at large apertures and high shutter speeds.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How does electronic first-curtain shutter work with a mechanical second curtain?
What are the disadvantages of using electronic first curtain shutter (EFCS)?
Sony α7R II shutter modes: mechanical vs electronic front-curtain vs silent—pros and cons?
Can very fast focal-plane shutter speeds cause visible diffraction blur?
Does using electronic shutter extend a camera’s shutter life?